Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Practice

Sample clients

Read what we know. Notice what we still need. Decide what you'd look for — then open the rules.

Texas

The Salinas plea

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

Plea bargain on a drug charge; the court followed the recommendation. Before trial, counsel filed a written motion to suppress the search, and the court denied it after a hearing. Sentence imposed Sept. 1.

What we still need

The certification's exact wording, and the date the suppression ruling was made.

What to decide

  • Can your client appeal after a plea bargain?
  • Does the certification say so?
  • What's the deadline, and which harm test applies?
Show the rules for The Salinas plea

Yes — on the suppression ruling. Counsel raised it by written motion, and the court ruled before trial (TRAP 25.2(a)(2)(A); CCP art. 44.02). Make sure the certification says so (TRAP 25.2(d)). File the notice of appeal in the trial court within 30 days after sentencing (TRAP 26.2(a)(1), 25.2(c)). A search claim is constitutional, so harm is tested under TRAP 44.2(a).

The Ortega hearsay

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

Jury trial for aggravated assault. A detective repeated what a neighbor told him; defense counsel said only "Objection." Overruled. Sentence: 12 years.

What we still need

The full exchange around the objection. Was the hearsay ground apparent from context?

What to decide

  • Did counsel preserve the complaint?
  • Can your client get bond pending appeal?
Show the rules for The Ortega hearsay

Probably not preserved. A bare "Objection" preserves nothing unless the ground was obvious from context (TRE 103(a)(1)(B); TRAP 33.1(a)(1)(A)). And no bond pending appeal: it's a felony with a sentence of 10 years or more (CCP art. 44.04(b)).

The Villarreal alibi witness

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

The judge excluded the defense's alibi witness. Counsel sat down without saying what the witness would have said.

What we still need

What the alibi witness would have said — from counsel, the witness, or an affidavit.

What to decide

  • What did counsel need to do to preserve the exclusion?
Show the rules for The Villarreal alibi witness

Counsel needed an offer of proof showing what the witness would have said (TRE 103(a)(2)). The court must allow it outside the jury's presence, before the charge is read (TRE 103(c)). If it never made the record, the fallback is a formal bill of exception (TRAP 33.2).

The Reyna charge

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

The charge omitted a self-defense instruction the evidence raised. Defense counsel made no written objection and requested nothing.

What we still need

The evidence that raised self-defense, with record cites.

What to decide

  • Was there charge error at all?
  • What should counsel have done?
  • When does a harm test come in?
Show the rules for The Reyna charge

Start with whether there was error at all. The court must give a written charge setting out the law applicable to the case (CCP art. 36.14). Settled practice: a trial court has no duty to submit a defensive issue that no one requested, so leaving out an unrequested self-defense instruction usually isn't charge error. That's different from a defensive instruction the court gave, but gave wrong. If counsel wanted the instruction, the way to get it was a written objection or a written requested instruction before the charge was read (CCP arts. 36.14, 36.15). The art. 36.19 harm tests come in only after error is found (CCP art. 36.19).

The Cantu lawyer

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

After a conviction, the client says trial counsel never interviewed two witnesses who would have helped. Nothing about it is in the record. Sentence imposed 12 days ago.

What we still need

Affidavits from the two witnesses and from trial counsel, in time for a day-30 motion.

What to decide

  • How do those facts get into a record?
  • Which clocks are running?
Show the rules for The Cantu lawyer

Through a motion for new trial, because the complaint needs facts that aren't in the record (TRAP 21.2). File it within 30 days after sentencing (21.4), present it within 10 days of filing (21.6), and expect a ruling within 75 days (21.8). A timely motion also pushes the notice deadline to 90 days (26.2(a)(2)). Miss this window and the claim waits for habeas (CCP art. 11.07).

The Garza indictment

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

On appeal, new counsel notices the indictment failed to allege an element. Nobody objected before trial.

What we still need

The indictment's text and the element it left out.

What to decide

  • Can new counsel raise the defect now?
Show the rules for The Garza indictment

No. An objection to a defect of form or substance in the indictment had to come before trial on the merits began. Without it, the complaint is waived — on appeal and in any postconviction proceeding (CCP art. 1.14(b)).

The Mendoza brief

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

The reporter's record was filed Oct. 1; the clerk's record Sept. 20. The main issue is legal sufficiency. The draft brief is 17,000 words.

What we still need

Both record-filing dates, confirmed from the court of appeals' docket.

What to decide

  • When is the brief due?
  • Is it too long?
  • Which record do you need?
Show the rules for The Mendoza brief

The brief is due 30 days after the later record was filed. That's Oct. 31, 2026 — a Saturday — so it's due Monday, Nov. 2 (TRAP 38.6(a), 4.1(a)). At 17,000 words it's over the 15,000-word limit (TRAP 9.4(i)(2)(B)). Cut it or move for leave (9.4(i)(4)), and include the word-count certificate (9.4(i)(3)). A sufficiency point needs all the evidence in the record (TRAP 34.6(c)(5)).

The Treviño remark

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

Ruling on an objection, the judge told the jury the officer's testimony "is about as solid as it gets." No objection.

What we still need

The judge's exact words, and whether the jury was told anything afterward.

What to decide

  • Which statute did the judge run into?
  • Does silence forfeit the complaint?
  • What still has to be shown?
Show the rules for The Treviño remark

The remark implicates CCP art. 38.05, which bars the judge from commenting on the weight of the evidence. The article says nothing about what happens if counsel stays silent. Case law, not rule text: in Proenza v. State the Court of Criminal Appeals held that an art. 38.05 complaint is not forfeited by the failure to object, because the right is waivable-only — so look for an express waiver rather than a missed objection. That settles only whether the complaint can be considered. Whether the comment violated the article, and whether it warrants relief, are separate questions — and objecting at the time is still the sound practice.

The Delgado affirmance

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

The court of appeals affirmed in an unpublished opinion on Sept. 1. Counsel thinks it conflicts with another court of appeals.

What we still need

The conflicting opinion, and whether anyone filed for rehearing.

What to decide

  • What are the next steps and deadlines?
  • What makes a PDR worth granting?
Show the rules for The Delgado affirmance

Rehearing is due in 15 days (TRAP 49.1). The PDR is due 30 days after the judgment, or after the last timely rehearing ruling (TRAP 68.2(a)). Keep it to 4,500 words (9.4(i)(2)(E)) and attach the opinion (68.4). Lead with the conflict (TRAP 66.3(a)). The opinion has no precedential value, but you may cite it as "(not designated for publication)" (TRAP 47.7(a)).

The Benavides lost appeal

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

Sentence imposed in January; no notice of appeal was ever filed. It is now September.

What we still need

What the client asked for, when, and what counsel did — letters, jail mail, affidavits.

What to decide

  • Is a direct appeal still possible?
  • Where does it go from here?
  • What about federal court?
Show the rules for The Benavides lost appeal

Not by direct appeal. The notice deadline and the 15-day extension window passed long ago (TRAP 26.2(a), 26.3). The way forward now is habeas under CCP art. 11.07: file in the convicting court, and the CCA decides whether to restore the appeal. And pin down the federal one-year clock now (28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)).

The Ramos lab report

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

Drug possession. Thirty days before trial, the State filed and served a lab certificate of analysis. The defense filed nothing. At trial, when the State offered the certificate, counsel objected that your client had a right to confront the chemist. Overruled.

What we still need

The certificate's filing and service dates, and how it was served.

What to decide

  • Was the objection timely?
  • What did the statute require?
Show the rules for The Ramos lab report

The certificate comes in without the analyst unless a written objection is filed, and served, at least 10 days before trial (CCP art. 38.41 § 4). The objection at trial came after that deadline, so the statute's condition for keeping the certificate out never happened. Check whether the State met its own 20-day filing and service requirement, which is in the same section.

The Soto outcry

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

Indecency with a child. On the first day of trial, the State announced it would call the child's aunt as the outcry witness. No notice had been given. Counsel objected, "Hearsay." Overruled, and the aunt testified.

What we still need

Whether any notice or summary was ever served, and whether a reliability hearing happened.

What to decide

  • What did the State have to do before trial?
  • Was the objection specific enough?
  • Which harm test applies?
Show the rules for The Soto outcry

The State had to give notice, name the witness, and provide a written summary at least 14 days before trial. The court also had to find the statement reliable at a hearing outside the jury (CCP art. 38.072 § 2(b)). "Hearsay" named the rule the statement had to get past. On appeal, argue that the art. 38.072 conditions weren't met, since the specific ground has to be apparent (TRE 103(a)(1)(B)). Unless the complaint is constitutional, harm is tested under TRAP 44.2(b).

The Castillo prior fight

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

Assault trial. At guilt-innocence, the State offered evidence that Castillo punched someone at a bar a year earlier. The defense had never requested extraneous-offense notice. Counsel objected, "Surprise — no notice." Overruled. No one asked for a limiting instruction.

What we still need

Whether the defense ever asked for notice, and how the bar fight was proved.

What to decide

  • Did the State owe notice?
  • What objections fit?
  • What about the missing instruction?
Show the rules for The Castillo prior fight

The State had to give notice only if the defense made a timely request, and it didn't (TRE 404(b)(2)). The objections that fit are character conformity (TRE 404(b)(1)) and unfair prejudice (TRE 403). With no request to limit the evidence, your client can't complain on appeal that it wasn't limited (TRE 105(b)(1)).

The Herrera video

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

Robbery. The defense offered a store's security video showing someone else near the register. The State objected, "Improper predicate." The store manager was on the stand, but counsel asked her nothing more. Excluded. Counsel sat down.

What we still need

What the manager knows about the recording system — for the offer of proof or a bill.

What to decide

  • What did authentication require?
  • What should the record show now?
  • Is it too late to fix?
Show the rules for The Herrera video

Authentication needs only evidence sufficient to support a finding that the video is what you say it is (TRE 901(a)). The manager could have described the recording system and shown that it produces an accurate result (TRE 901(b)(9)), or testified from her own knowledge (901(b)(1)). Once the video was excluded, counsel needed an offer of proof outside the jury, before the charge was read (TRE 103(a)(2), (c)). Without one, the fallback is a formal bill of exception, due 60 days after sentencing — or 90 with a timely motion for new trial (TRAP 33.2(e)(2)). If the exclusion kept out a defense, argue harm under TRAP 44.2(a) or (b).

The Morales texts

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

Assault. On cross, the complainant denied telling a friend she "made the whole thing up." The defense then offered the friend's screenshot of that text. The State objected, "Hearsay." Counsel said, "It's just evidence she lied." Excluded.

What we still need

Where the screenshot came from, and the cross-examination transcript.

What to decide

  • What's the purpose of the offer?
  • Was the foundation laid?
  • How should counsel have framed it?
Show the rules for The Morales texts

Offered to impeach, the text is a prior inconsistent statement. Extrinsic proof of it comes in only after the witness is told its contents, time, place, and recipient, and fails to unequivocally admit it (TRE 613(a)). If the evidence is admissible only for impeachment, the offer has to be limited to that purpose, or the exclusion can't be complained of (TRE 105(b)(2)). Then make an offer of proof (TRE 103(a)(2)).

The Flores phone records

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

Burglary. The defense served cell-phone records with a custodian's affidavit five days before trial, to show Flores was across town. The State objected to the late service. Excluded. No custodian was called.

What we still need

The service date and method, and whether the records custodian can testify.

What to decide

  • What does the affidavit option require?
  • What else could counsel have done?
Show the rules for The Flores phone records

The affidavit option requires serving the record and affidavit at least 14 days before trial (TRE 902(10)(A)). For good cause, the court may still treat the record as presumptively authentic, so ask for that. Or call the custodian or another qualified witness to prove the business-record elements live (TRE 803(6)(D)). Either way, make an offer of proof when the records are excluded (TRE 103(a)(2)).

The Guzman writ

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

Guzman filed an art. 11.07 application raising ineffective assistance. The State received it on Wednesday, Mar. 4, 2026, and never answered. The trial court never entered any order. Guzman's lawyer later wants to add a new ground in a memorandum.

What we still need

Proof of the date the State received the application, and the full writ docket.

What to decide

  • What does the State's silence mean?
  • What does the court's silence mean?
  • Can a ground be added in the memorandum?
Show the rules for The Guzman writ

The State's answer was due 30 days after receipt, Apr. 3, 2026, and anything it didn't admit is deemed denied (CCP art. 11.07 § 3(b)). The court then had 20 days, to Apr. 23, to find controverted, previously unresolved facts. Doing nothing counts as a finding that there are none, and the clerk sends the case up (§ 3(c)). Had the court designated issues, it would have had until Aug. 31 — 180 days after the State's receipt — to resolve them (TRAP 73.5). A new ground has to go on the form; one raised only in a memorandum won't be considered (TRAP 73.1(c)).

The Rocha probation writ

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What we know

Rocha pleaded guilty and was placed on community supervision. Rocha now says the plea was involuntary because counsel misstated its consequences. No appeal was filed. Rocha is still on supervision.

What we still need

The supervision order, the plea papers, and what counsel said about the plea's consequences.

What to decide

  • Which article applies, and where is it filed?
  • What are the State's and the court's clocks?
  • Where does a denial go?
Show the rules for The Rocha probation writ

CCP art. 11.072 applies to someone who is or was on community supervision, filed in the court that imposed it (§ 2). It isn't available if the relief could be had by appeal under art. 44.02 and TRAP 25.2 (§ 3(a)). Serve the State immediately. It may answer within 30 days, plus one 30-day extension for good cause (§ 5(c)). The court must rule in writing within 60 days after the answer (§ 6(a)). A denial is appealed under art. 44.02 and TRAP 31 (§ 8).

Federal

The Alvarado federal plea

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Post-trial motions and the notice of appeal
  3. 3The record and the brief
  4. 4Harmless error and plain error
  5. 5After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari
  6. 6§ 2254: a state prisoner in federal court
  7. 7§ 2255: a federal prisoner's motion
  8. 8Appealing a habeas denial

What we know

Alvarado pleaded guilty in federal district court under a plea agreement that waives appeal of the sentence. Judgment was entered Tuesday, Sept. 1, 2026. Now Alvarado wants to appeal the sentence.

What we still need

The plea agreement's waiver language and the judgment's entry date on the docket.

What to decide

  • When is the notice due?
  • Can the deadline be extended?
  • What does the waiver do?
Show the rules for The Alvarado federal plea

The notice is due 14 days after judgment was entered: Tuesday, Sept. 15, 2026 (FRAP 4(b)(1)(A), 26(a)(1)). For excusable neglect or good cause, the district court may extend that by up to 30 days (FRAP 4(b)(4)). The court had to explain the waiver's terms before accepting the plea (FRCrP 11(b)(1)(N)). Read the waiver itself: its terms decide what it covers, and the rules don't say when a court will enforce it. If your client asks, the clerk must file the notice (FRCrP 32(j)(2)).

The Guerra suppression

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Post-trial motions and the notice of appeal
  3. 3The record and the brief
  4. 4Harmless error and plain error
  5. 5After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari
  6. 6§ 2254: a state prisoner in federal court
  7. 7§ 2255: a federal prisoner's motion
  8. 8Appealing a habeas denial

What we know

A federal firearm case. Trial counsel knew about the traffic stop before trial but never moved to suppress. Instead, counsel objected when the gun was offered at trial. Guerra was convicted.

What we still need

When counsel learned about the stop, and the motion deadline the court set.

What to decide

  • Was the suppression claim preserved?
  • Is there another way to raise it?
Show the rules for The Guerra suppression

Probably not preserved. Suppression must be raised by pretrial motion if the basis was reasonably available (FRCrP 12(b)(3)(C)). A later motion is untimely unless there's good cause (12(c)(3)), and a trial objection doesn't substitute. If counsel's failure is the real problem, that's an ineffective-assistance claim for a § 2255 motion in the sentencing court (28 U.S.C. § 2255(a)), on a one-year clock (§ 2255(f)).

The Ibarra jury charge

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Post-trial motions and the notice of appeal
  3. 3The record and the brief
  4. 4Harmless error and plain error
  5. 5After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari
  6. 6§ 2254: a state prisoner in federal court
  7. 7§ 2255: a federal prisoner's motion
  8. 8Appealing a habeas denial

What we know

The instructions left out an element of the offense, and nobody objected. Ibarra was convicted, and the appeal is pending.

What we still need

The charge as given, the statute's elements, and the evidence on the missing element.

What to decide

  • Which standard applies?
  • Who has to show what?
Show the rules for The Ibarra jury charge

With no specific objection before the jury retired, review is limited to plain error (FRCrP 30(d), 52(b)). The error has to be plain and has to affect substantial rights — and even then, the court "may" consider it (52(b)). Settled practice puts the burden on the defendant under plain-error review.

The Luna federal petition

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Post-trial motions and the notice of appeal
  3. 3The record and the brief
  4. 4Harmless error and plain error
  5. 5After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari
  6. 6§ 2254: a state prisoner in federal court
  7. 7§ 2255: a federal prisoner's motion
  8. 8Appealing a habeas denial

What we know

A Texas conviction. The CCA refused Luna's PDR on Mar. 4, 2025, and no cert petition was filed. Luna filed an art. 11.07 application on Jan. 10, 2026, and the CCA denied it without written order on Aug. 12, 2026. Now Luna wants to go to federal court.

What we still need

Certified filing and disposition dates for the PDR and the 11.07.

What to decide

  • When did the federal year start?
  • How much of it is left?
  • Which claims can Luna raise?
Show the rules for The Luna federal petition

The time to seek cert ran out 90 days after the PDR refusal — June 2, 2025 (Sup. Ct. R. 13.1) — and the one-year period runs from then (28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)(1)(A)). Counting under Civil Rule 6(a), with the 11.07 treated as pending from filing day through disposition day: 221 days ran before it was filed, and the 215 days it was pending don't count (§ 2244(d)(2)). That leaves 144 days from Aug. 12, 2026. Day 144 is Sunday, Jan. 3, 2027, so the last day is Monday, Jan. 4, 2027 (FRCP 6(a)(1)(C)). This worked example uses the stated dates and counting assumptions; recalculate using the dates in your case. Claims raised in the 11.07 are exhausted (§ 2254(b)(1)(A), (c)). Any claim the CCA denied on the merits faces § 2254(d). Plead every ground in the petition (§ 2254 Rule 2(c)).

The Peña § 2255

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Post-trial motions and the notice of appeal
  3. 3The record and the brief
  4. 4Harmless error and plain error
  5. 5After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari
  6. 6§ 2254: a state prisoner in federal court
  7. 7§ 2255: a federal prisoner's motion
  8. 8Appealing a habeas denial

What we know

A federal drug conviction, affirmed by the Fifth Circuit on Feb. 10, 2026. No rehearing, no cert petition. Peña says trial counsel never passed along a plea offer.

What we still need

The Fifth Circuit's judgment date, and proof of the plea offer.

What to decide

  • When does the year run?
  • Where does Peña file?
  • If the motion is denied, how does Peña appeal?
Show the rules for The Peña § 2255

The year runs from when the conviction "becomes final" (§ 2255(f)(1)). The statute doesn't define that. Settled practice treats it as the close of the 90-day cert window: May 11, 2026 (Sup. Ct. R. 13.1). File in the court that imposed the sentence (§ 2255(a)), with every ground pleaded under penalty of perjury (§ 2255 Rule 2(b)). If the motion is denied, Peña needs a certificate of appealability to appeal (28 U.S.C. § 2253(c)(1)(B)). The notice of appeal is due in 60 days, because the United States is a party (§ 2255 Rule 11(b); FRAP 4(a)(1)(B)).

The Quintero COA

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Post-trial motions and the notice of appeal
  3. 3The record and the brief
  4. 4Harmless error and plain error
  5. 5After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari
  6. 6§ 2254: a state prisoner in federal court
  7. 7§ 2255: a federal prisoner's motion
  8. 8Appealing a habeas denial

What we know

The district court denied Quintero's § 2254 petition, which challenged a Texas conviction, on Thursday, Aug. 20, 2026. It also denied a certificate of appealability. Counsel plans to ask the court to reconsider the certificate.

What we still need

The entry dates of the judgment and of the order on the certificate.

What to decide

  • When is the notice due?
  • Does the motion to reconsider help?
  • How does Quintero get a certificate now?
Show the rules for The Quintero COA

FRAP 4(a) sets the deadline (§ 2254 Rule 11(b)): 30 days after entry (FRAP 4(a)(1)(A)). Day 30 is Saturday, Sept. 19, so the notice is due Monday, Sept. 21, 2026 (FRAP 26(a)(1)(C)). Asking the court to reconsider the certificate won't extend that (§ 2254 Rule 11(a)). Instead, ask a circuit judge for a certificate — and if you file no express request, the notice of appeal counts as one (FRAP 22(b)(1)–(2)). The certificate must name the issues that make a substantial showing that a constitutional right was denied (28 U.S.C. § 2253(c)(2)–(3)).

The Ybarra brief

  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Post-trial motions and the notice of appeal
  3. 3The record and the brief
  4. 4Harmless error and plain error
  5. 5After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari
  6. 6§ 2254: a state prisoner in federal court
  7. 7§ 2255: a federal prisoner's motion
  8. 8Appealing a habeas denial

What we know

A federal fraud appeal in the Fifth Circuit. The record was filed Friday, Aug. 28, 2026. The draft opening brief runs 14,200 words, and the jurisdictional statement cites the statutes but gives no dates.

What we still need

The record-filing date on the docket, and the Fifth Circuit's briefing notice.

What to decide

  • When is the brief due?
  • Is it too long?
  • What is missing from the jurisdictional statement?
Show the rules for The Ybarra brief

FRAP 31(a)(1) would put the brief 40 days after the record was filed, but a circuit may set its own time by local rule (FRAP 31(a)(2)), and the Fifth Circuit does: the appellant must send the brief to the clerk not later than 40 days after the date of the briefing notice (5th Cir. R. 31.3). Count from the notice, not from the record, and calendar an extension request to reach the clerk at least 7 days before the due date (5th Cir. R. 31.4.1). At 14,200 words, it's over the 13,000-word limit for a principal brief (FRAP 32(a)(7)(B)(i)). The jurisdictional statement also needs the filing dates that show the appeal is timely, plus an assertion of finality or another basis for jurisdiction (FRAP 28(a)(4)(C)–(D)). And each issue needs a statement of the standard of review (FRAP 28(a)(8)(B)).