Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Checklist

Issue spotter

Error isn't yet relief. For each complaint: how it had to be preserved, how the court reviews it, what else you must show, and what the court can do.

Sufficiency of the evidence

Texas

1 · Preserved how?

No trial objection needed — the rules set no preservation step. If you request a partial reporter's record, it must include all the evidence (TRAP 34.6(c)(5)).

2 · Standard of review

Settled practice: viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the verdict, could any rational factfinder have found each element beyond a reasonable doubt?

3 · Harm

None. If the evidence is insufficient, the remedy is acquittal, not a harm analysis.

4 · Remedy

Settled practice: reverse and render an acquittal — the judgment the trial court should have rendered (TRAP 43.2(c)).

Federal

1 · Preserved how?

A Rule 29 motion preserves it — made during trial, or within 14 days after the verdict or the jury's discharge. No trial motion is required before a post-verdict one (FRCrP 29(a), (c)(1), (c)(3)). Settled practice: without any Rule 29 motion, review is far narrower, akin to plain error.

2 · Standard of review

Settled practice: the same rational-factfinder question, viewing the evidence in the government's favor.

3 · Harm

The court must acquit on any offense the evidence can't support (FRCrP 29(a)). No harm analysis applies.

4 · Remedy

A finding that the evidence was legally insufficient ordinarily requires reversal and a judgment of acquittal on that offense. The government doesn't get a new trial to supply missing proof. Reforming the judgment to a lesser included offense is a separate question. Section 2106 lists the court's general powers; it doesn't turn insufficiency into ordinary trial error.

Search, seizure, and suppression

Texas

1 · Preserved how?

A motion to suppress, and a ruling on it (TRAP 33.1). In a plea-bargain case under TRAP 25.2(a)(2), the appeal is limited to matters raised by written motion filed and ruled on before trial, matters the trial court gives permission to appeal, or an appeal a statute expressly authorizes. A suppression motion alone doesn't guarantee an appeal — check the certification (Stage 4).

2 · Standard of review

Settled practice: deference to the trial court's findings of historical fact; legal questions reviewed de novo.

3 · Harm

Article 38.23 states the exclusion rule and the jury instruction; it sets no harm standard. Take harm from the error's character: constitutional suppression error under TRAP 44.2(a), where the court must reverse unless it determines beyond a reasonable doubt that the error did not contribute to the conviction or punishment; purely statutory evidentiary error under 44.2(b), disregarded unless it affects substantial rights. A refused art. 38.23 jury instruction is charge error, reviewed under CCP art. 36.19 — reversible if the error was calculated to injure the defendant's rights, or if the record shows no fair and impartial trial.

4 · Remedy

Usually reverse and remand for a new trial (TRAP 43.2(d); CCP art. 44.29(a)). If the error touched only punishment in a non-capital case, a new punishment hearing (CCP art. 44.29(b)).

Federal

1 · Preserved how?

A pretrial motion, if the basis was reasonably available (FRCrP 12(b)(3)(C)). If it's late, only for good cause (12(c)(3)).

2 · Standard of review

Settled practice: deference to the district court's fact findings; legal questions reviewed de novo.

3 · Harm

If preserved, the error is disregarded unless it affects substantial rights (FRCrP 52(a)).

4 · Remedy

The court may affirm, modify, vacate, set aside, or reverse, and remand for further proceedings (28 U.S.C. § 2106).

Evidence admitted or excluded

Texas · Evidence admitted over objection

1 · Preserved how?

A timely, specific objection or motion to strike (TRE 103(a)(1)). No need to renew it after a hearing outside the jury (TRE 103(b)).

2 · Standard of review

Settled practice: abuse of discretion.

3 · Harm

Non-constitutional error is disregarded unless it affects substantial rights (TRAP 44.2(b); TRE 103(a)).

4 · Remedy

Usually reverse and remand for a new trial (TRAP 43.2(d); CCP art. 44.29(a)). If the error touched only punishment in a non-capital case, a new punishment hearing (CCP art. 44.29(b)).

Texas · Defense evidence excluded

1 · Preserved how?

Lay the predicate, then make an offer of proof showing the evidence and its foundation (TRE 103(a)(2), (c)). Limit the offer to the proper purpose (TRE 105(b)(2)). If needed, a formal bill of exception within 60 days after sentencing, or 90 with a timely motion for new trial (TRAP 33.2(e)(2)).

2 · Standard of review

Settled practice: abuse of discretion.

3 · Harm

TRAP 44.2(b) — or 44.2(a) if the exclusion violated a constitutional right.

4 · Remedy

Usually reverse and remand for a new trial (TRAP 43.2(d); CCP art. 44.29(a)). If the error touched only punishment in a non-capital case, a new punishment hearing (CCP art. 44.29(b)).

Federal · Evidence admitted or excluded

1 · Preserved how?

A timely objection or motion to strike, with the specific ground, or an offer of proof for excluded evidence. No need to renew after a definitive ruling (FRE 103(a)–(b)).

2 · Standard of review

Settled practice: abuse of discretion.

3 · Harm

The error must affect a substantial right (FRE 103(a)). If it wasn't preserved, it's plain error or nothing (FRE 103(e); FRCrP 52(b)).

4 · Remedy

The court may affirm, modify, vacate, set aside, or reverse, and remand for further proceedings (28 U.S.C. § 2106).

Jury charge and instructions

Texas

1 · Preserved how?

Written objections before the charge is read, each ground spelled out, or written requested instructions (CCP arts. 36.14, 36.15).

2 · Standard of review

Settled practice: first decide whether the charge was wrong; only then apply art. 36.19.

3 · Harm

Objected: reversal if the error was calculated to injure your client's rights (settled practice: "some harm"). Not objected: only if your client didn't get a fair and impartial trial ("egregious harm") (CCP art. 36.19).

4 · Remedy

Usually reverse and remand for a new trial (TRAP 43.2(d); CCP art. 44.29(a)). If the error touched only punishment in a non-capital case, a new punishment hearing (CCP art. 44.29(b)).

Federal

1 · Preserved how?

A specific objection, with grounds, before the jury retires (FRCrP 30(d)).

2 · Standard of review

No rule states it. Your brief must state it for each issue (FRAP 28(a)(8)(B)).

3 · Harm

Without one, only plain error that affects substantial rights (FRCrP 30(d), 52(b)).

4 · Remedy

The court may affirm, modify, vacate, set aside, or reverse, and remand for further proceedings (28 U.S.C. § 2106).

Extraneous offenses

Texas

1 · Preserved how?

Object on character conformity (TRE 404(b)(1)) and, separately, on TRE 403. Notice is owed on a timely request (TRE 404(b)(2); CCP art. 37.07 § 3(g)) — except in an art. 38.37 case, where the State owes it 30 days before trial without any request, and a § 2-a hearing outside the jury's presence comes first (CCP art. 38.37 §§ 2-a, 3). Ask for a limiting instruction (TRE 105(b)(1)).

2 · Standard of review

Settled practice: abuse of discretion.

3 · Harm

Non-constitutional: TRAP 44.2(b).

4 · Remedy

Usually reverse and remand for a new trial (TRAP 43.2(d); CCP art. 44.29(a)). If the error touched only punishment in a non-capital case, a new punishment hearing (CCP art. 44.29(b)).

Outcry statements

Texas

1 · Preserved how?

Object that the art. 38.072 § 2(b) conditions weren't met: notice 14 days out, the named witness, a written summary, a reliability hearing outside the jury, and a child who testifies or is available.

2 · Standard of review

Settled practice: abuse of discretion.

3 · Harm

Non-constitutional: TRAP 44.2(b).

4 · Remedy

Usually reverse and remand for a new trial (TRAP 43.2(d); CCP art. 44.29(a)). If the error touched only punishment in a non-capital case, a new punishment hearing (CCP art. 44.29(b)).

Lab certificates and custody affidavits

Texas

1 · Preserved how?

A written objection, filed and served at least 10 days before trial (CCP arts. 38.41 § 4, 38.42 § 4).

2 · Standard of review

No rule states it.

3 · Harm

TRAP 44.2(b), or 44.2(a) if the complaint is constitutional.

4 · Remedy

Usually reverse and remand for a new trial (TRAP 43.2(d); CCP art. 44.29(a)). If the error touched only punishment in a non-capital case, a new punishment hearing (CCP art. 44.29(b)).

Confessions

Texas

1 · Preserved how?

Raise voluntariness; the court must rule outside the jury and file findings (CCP art. 38.22 § 6). If the evidence raises a fact issue, ask for the jury instruction (CCP arts. 38.22 § 6, 38.23(a)).

2 · Standard of review

Settled practice: deference to the trial court's findings of historical fact; legal questions reviewed de novo.

3 · Harm

TRAP 44.2(a) if constitutional; otherwise 44.2(b). Charge error: CCP art. 36.19.

4 · Remedy

Usually reverse and remand for a new trial (TRAP 43.2(d); CCP art. 44.29(a)). If the error touched only punishment in a non-capital case, a new punishment hearing (CCP art. 44.29(b)).

The judge's comments

Texas

1 · Preserved how?

Object and get a ruling (TRAP 33.1). Case law, not rule text: for an art. 38.05 complaint, the Court of Criminal Appeals held in Proenza v. State that the right is waivable-only, so silence alone does not forfeit it — look for an express waiver. Don't generalize that holding to other complaints.

2 · Standard of review

No rule states it.

3 · Harm

CCP art. 38.05 states the prohibition. Preservation, whether the statute was violated, and harm under TRAP 44.2 are three separate questions.

4 · Remedy

Usually reverse and remand for a new trial (TRAP 43.2(d); CCP art. 44.29(a)). If the error touched only punishment in a non-capital case, a new punishment hearing (CCP art. 44.29(b)).

Charging instrument

Texas

1 · Preserved how?

Object before trial on the merits begins, or it's waived — on appeal and in postconviction proceedings too (CCP art. 1.14(b)).

2 · Standard of review

—

3 · Harm

—

4 · Remedy

None if the objection wasn't made before trial (CCP art. 1.14(b)).

Ineffective assistance

Texas

1 · Preserved how?

Facts outside the record need a motion for new trial, timely filed and presented (TRAP 21.2, 21.4, 21.6), or a habeas application later (CCP art. 11.07).

2 · Standard of review

Settled practice: deficient performance and resulting prejudice — a constitutional test no rule states.

3 · Harm

A constitutional claim. The rules don't state the test.

4 · Remedy

Usually reverse and remand for a new trial (TRAP 43.2(d); CCP art. 44.29(a)). If the error touched only punishment in a non-capital case, a new punishment hearing (CCP art. 44.29(b)).

Plea and certification

Texas

1 · Preserved how?

Check the certification and the notice against the record (TRAP 25.2(a)(2), (d), (f)).

2 · Standard of review

No rule states it.

3 · Harm

No harm test. The certification is a record requirement: the appeal must be dismissed if one showing the right of appeal never becomes part of the record, but it can be corrected (TRAP 25.2(d); 37.1; 34.5(c)).

4 · Remedy

Amend or supplement the certification (TRAP 25.2(f); 34.5(c)(2)).

Jury selection (Batson)

Texas

1 · Preserved how?

Object after the strike lists are delivered and before the jury is impaneled (CCP art. 35.261(a)).

2 · Standard of review

Settled practice: deference to the trial court's finding on purposeful discrimination.

3 · Harm

The statute's remedy is a new array (CCP art. 35.261(b)).

4 · Remedy

At trial, a new array (CCP art. 35.261(b)). On appeal: TRAP 43.2(d).

"Settled practice" marks a point the rules don't state; it's given in one sentence, without case names.