Foundations
Elements, evidence, and burdens
Before the stages: what must be proved, how much must be proved, and how the proof gets in front of the decision-maker — and why each question still matters on appeal.
If I have learned anything about the law, it is that it begins where it ends. A jury trial begins with jury selection and ends with the jury “selecting” a just outcome. Likewise, a good trial attorney will begin where it ends: the jury instructions. They give you every element you must focus on when you review the case with the jury before deliberation. They are the jury's roadmap and guide.
An appeal is read the same way, from the end back. So three questions come first. What must be proved? How much must be proved? And how does the proof get before the decision-maker?
Four ideas to keep apart
Elements
What must be established?
The statutory elements of the offense, compared with the jury instructions and the evidence (Penal Code § 2.01; CCP art. 36.14).
Burden of production
Is there enough evidence to put an issue before the jury?
A defense or affirmative defense isn't submitted unless evidence supporting it is admitted (Penal Code §§ 2.03(c), 2.04(c)).
Burden of persuasion
Who must persuade the factfinder, and to what degree?
The State, beyond a reasonable doubt, on every element (Penal Code § 2.01). On an affirmative defense, the defendant, by a preponderance (§ 2.04(d)).
Standard of review
How does the appellate court examine the challenged ruling?
A different question entirely — asked about a ruling, not about guilt. See the Issue spotter.
What must be proved (the elements)
In a criminal case, the answer starts with a statute: no person may be convicted unless each element of the offense is proved beyond a reasonable doubt (Penal Code § 2.01). The court must give the jury a written charge setting out the law applicable to the case (CCP art. 36.14). That charge is the checklist the jury decides by. On appeal, compare the charge with the governing law and the record.
How much must be proved (burdens)
It is all well and good to know what you need to prove. However, what degree of conviction do you need from your jurors? We have all had situations in our day-to-day lives where we have a feeling that a conclusion is correct, or where we may even doubt our own perception. We may be positive that we saw our friend at a store last week because he was wearing a hat he always wears, but less sure that we saw him yesterday because he had shaved and was wearing a hoodie.
A standard of proof tells the factfinder how confident it must be before it answers a question yes. If the party bearing the burden does not persuade the factfinder to the required degree, that party loses on the proposition it had to prove. That is why it is, after all, a burden.
Beyond a reasonable doubt
From the lowly misdemeanor all the way up to capital murder, the State's burden is the same: it must prove each element beyond a reasonable doubt (Penal Code § 2.01). The same burden applies when the State must negate a statutory exception (§ 2.02(b)).
Defense or affirmative defense? (production versus persuasion)
“The defendant raised it” doesn't tell you who bears the burden. For a defense, evidence supporting the defense must be admitted before the issue is submitted to the jury — and once it is, a reasonable doubt on it requires acquittal (Penal Code § 2.03(c)–(d)). For an affirmative defense, supporting evidence must likewise be admitted, and then the defendant must prove it by a preponderance of the evidence — more likely than not (§ 2.04(c)–(d)).
Clear and convincing evidence
This intermediate standard asks for more than a preponderance but less than proof beyond a reasonable doubt. In criminal practice you'll meet it in federal habeas: a state court's findings of fact are presumed correct, and the applicant must rebut them by clear and convincing evidence (28 U.S.C. § 2254(e)(1)). That burden applies to particular factual findings — it isn't the standard for winning relief. Separately, CCP art. 11.07 § 4(a)(2) sets a particular subsequent-application gateway: a preponderance showing that, but for a violation of the United States Constitution, no rational juror could have found guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
How the proof gets before the decision-maker (evidence)
Court cases start in the real world: a traffic stop, a fight outside a bar, a phone call. The courtroom is not the real world; it is an artificial one. It is counsel's job to build a model of what happened in the real world. How do you know what model to build? By reference to the elements that must be proved. The elements are the blueprint for the model that we need to build.
Imagine that the courtroom is a vacuum. Nothing is there unless we put it there. A few things we may assume — the rules of language, the facts of everyday living, and ordinary reasoning. Everything else comes in through the rules of evidence.
The model-building picture is Irving Younger's. Watch his lectures on evidence and trial advocacy: Irving Younger Online (NITA)
Must this fact be proved at all? (judicial notice)
The court may notice a fact that isn't subject to reasonable dispute because it is generally known in the trial court's territory, or can be accurately and readily determined from sources whose accuracy can't reasonably be questioned (TRE 201(b)). In a criminal case, the jury must be told it may or may not accept the noticed fact as conclusive (TRE 201(f)).
Relevant, and not excluded
Evidence is relevant if it has any tendency to make a fact of consequence more or less probable (TRE 401). Relevant evidence comes in unless a constitution, a statute, or a rule says otherwise; irrelevant evidence never does (TRE 402).
Proving what a writing says
To prove the contents of a writing, recording, or photograph, you need the original — unless the rules or other law provide otherwise (TRE 1002). A duplicate usually works as well as the original (TRE 1003). Testimony about what a record says, with no record in evidence, is where this rule bites.
The forms proof takes
Testimony, documents, real evidence (the thing itself), and demonstrative aids. Each needs its own foundation — the predicate — and each lands in a different part of the appellate record. Stage 3 walks through laying the foundation and making a record when it's kept out.
Then, on appeal
At trial, counsel builds the evidentiary record. On appeal, counsel identifies what that record establishes, which rulings are challenged, and how the governing law applies.
Keep three things apart. The burden of proving guilt, the standard for reviewing a ruling, and the test for harm do different jobs — and a brief that blurs them usually loses the thread.
Stage 1: Preserve it at trial · Stage 3: Predicates and offers of proof · Stage 8: Harm · Issue spotter