Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Federal · Appellate review · Stage 5 of 8

After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari

You lost in the circuit. What now, and how fast?

Stage 5 of 8 · View all stages
  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Post-trial motions and the notice of appeal
  3. 3The record and the brief
  4. 4Harmless error and plain error
  5. 5After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari
  6. 6§ 2254: a state prisoner in federal court
  7. 7§ 2255: a federal prisoner's motion
  8. 8Appealing a habeas denial

Lost in the circuit? You have 14 days to ask for rehearing and 90 to ask the Supreme Court. For a federal prisoner, the end of this stage usually starts the § 2255 clock.

Do this

  1. Calendar rehearing: 14 days after judgment (FRAP 40(d)(1)).
  2. Calendar cert: 90 days after judgment or the denial of rehearing — not the mandate (Sup. Ct. R. 13.1, 13.3).
  3. Need more time for cert? Apply at least 10 days before it's due (Sup. Ct. R. 13.5).
  4. Write down the date the cert window closes.

See it

Step by stepAfter the circuit rules
  1. Day 0

    The court of appeals enters judgment.

  2. +14

    Petition for rehearing (panel, en banc, or both) due.

    FRAP 40(d)(1)

  3. +7

    The mandate issues 7 days after the rehearing time runs out or rehearing is denied.

    FRAP 41(b)

  4. +90

    Cert petition due 90 days after judgment — or after rehearing is denied. Not from the mandate.

    Sup. Ct. R. 13.1, 13.3

  5. +60

    The most a Justice may extend it, for good cause.

    Sup. Ct. R. 13.5

Rules to know

FRAP 40(a), (b)

You can seek panel rehearing, rehearing en banc, or both — in one document, unless a local rule says otherwise. A panel petition must state with particularity each point of law or fact the court overlooked or misapprehended. An en banc petition must open by showing a conflict (with the circuit, the Supreme Court, or another circuit) or a question of exceptional importance. Rehearing en banc is not favored.

FRAP 40(d)(1), (d)(3)

Deadline: 14 days

File within 14 days after judgment is entered, or after an amended decision. But in a civil case the petition may be filed within 45 days if one of the parties is the United States, a United States agency, or a United States officer or employee sued in an official capacity (FRAP 40(d)(1)) — which reaches an appeal in a § 2255 proceeding, where the United States is the respondent. A § 2254 appeal, where the respondent is a state official, keeps the 14 days. The limit is 3,900 words, or 15 pages if handwritten or typewritten. No response unless the court orders one.

5th Cir. R. 40.1, 40.2.2

Deadline: —

In the Fifth Circuit, panel rehearing and en banc rehearing take separate petitions; the local rule is the one FRAP 40 defers to. The en banc petition must not be incorporated in the panel petition and must be complete in itself — it may not adopt anything by reference from the panel petition or from any other brief or motion in the case.

5th Cir. R. 40.1.4, 40.2.4

Deadline: received, not mailed

The clerk must receive the petition within the FRAP 40(d)(1) time. Putting it in the mail on the last day is not enough; count backward from receipt.

FRAP 41(b)

Deadline: 7 days

The mandate issues 7 days after the rehearing deadline passes, or 7 days after the court denies a timely rehearing petition or motion to stay the mandate — whichever is later.

Sup. Ct. R. 13.1, 13.3

Deadline: 90 days

A cert petition is due 90 days after the judgment of a U.S. court of appeals or a state court of last resort. If a lower state court's judgment was subject to discretionary review, the 90 days run from the order denying review. The clock runs from the judgment, not the mandate. A timely rehearing petition restarts it from the denial of rehearing.

Sup. Ct. R. 13.5

Deadline: +60 days

For good cause, a Justice may add up to 60 days. Apply at least 10 days before the petition is due, except in extraordinary circumstances.

Traps

  • The cert clock runs from the judgment or the denial of rehearing — never from the mandate (Sup. Ct. R. 13.3).
  • In a Texas case that reached the CCA, the 90 days run from the refusal of the PDR, and finality comes when that certiorari period expires — not on the refusal date itself (Sup. Ct. R. 13.1; 28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)(1)(A)). If no PDR was sought, don't add 90 days: direct review ended when the time for the available state review expired. Fix the ending event before you count.

Practice this stage

Try The Luna federal petition

Next in this procedure

Federal conviction: § 2255

This lesson ends the federal direct appeal. For a federal prisoner, collateral review continues under § 2255; § 2254 is for a state judgment.

Curriculum order: Stage 6: § 2254: a state prisoner in federal court

← Back to Stage 4: Harmless error and plain error