Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Texas · Postconviction · Stage 10 of 10

Beyond the appeal: habeas

The appeal is over, or it was lost. How does a Texas writ actually move?

Stage 10 of 10 · View all stages
  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

The appeal is over — or it never happened. Is that the end? Not necessarily. A writ of habeas corpus lets your client raise what the appeal couldn't, usually claims that depend on new facts. Texas has a different writ for each situation, so the first job is picking the right one.

Do this

  1. Use the tree below to pick the article: 11.07, 11.072, 11.071, 11.08, or 11.09.
  2. Identify the exact judgment you're challenging, and whether direct review is over.
  3. For art. 11.07: put every ground on the CCA's prescribed form. A ground raised only in the memorandum won't be considered (TRAP 73.1(a), (c)).
  4. For art. 11.07: calendar the State's 30 days, the court's 20, and the 180-day limit (CCP art. 11.07 § 3; TRAP 73.5).
  5. For art. 11.072: serve the State immediately. It may answer within 30 days, plus one 30-day extension, and the court must rule within 60 days after the answer (CCP art. 11.072 §§ 5–6).
  6. For art. 11.071 (death sentence): it has its own procedure and deadlines. Read the article in full first (CCP art. 11.071 § 1).
  7. In every case, track the federal one-year clock at the same time (28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)).

See it

Decision treeWhich Texas writ?

Where is the case now?

  • Charged, not yet convicted

    Felony or misdemeanor?

    • Felony

      Apply to the judge of the court where the indictment or information is pending, or another judge the article names.

      CCP art. 11.08

    • Misdemeanor

      Apply to the judge of the court where the information is pending, or another judge the article names.

      CCP art. 11.09(a)

  • Currently or previously on community supervision

    Was supervision revoked and a sentence imposed?

    • No — still on it, or completed it

      Article 11.072, filed in the court that imposed supervision.

      CCP art. 11.072 § 2

    • Yes

      Identify the judgment being challenged, and whether direct review is still available or pending. Check finality before choosing art. 11.07.

      CCP art. 11.07 § 3(a)

  • Final conviction

    What was the judgment?

    • Felony, any sentence but death

      Article 11.07: file with the convicting court's clerk. It's returnable to the CCA.

      CCP art. 11.07 §§ 1, 3

    • Death sentence

      Article 11.071, its own procedure.

      CCP art. 11.071 § 1

    • Misdemeanor

      Apply to the judge of the court that convicted.

      CCP art. 11.09(b)

The State's answer time, the deadlines, and the appeal differ by article. An 11.072 denial goes to the court of appeals; an 11.07 is decided by the CCA.

Step by stepAn 11.07 writ, day by day
  1. Day 0

    The State receives the application from the clerk.

  2. Day 30

    The State's answer is due. Anything not admitted is deemed denied.

    CCP art. 11.07 § 3(b)

  3. +20

    The court designates fact issues — or its silence is a finding that there are none, and the case goes up.

    CCP art. 11.07 § 3(c)–(d)

  4. 7 days

    Minimum notice to both sides before any hearing.

    CCP art. 11.07 § 6

  5. +10

    After receiving findings and conclusions, 10 days to object.

    TRAP 73.4(b)(2)

  6. Day 180

    Designated issues must be resolved, unless the CCA extended the time.

    TRAP 73.5

  7. Day 181

    The clerk forwards the record to the CCA.

    TRAP 73.4(b)(5)

Counted from the day the State receives the application.

Rules to know

CCP art. 11.07 §§ 1, 3(a)–(b)

Deadline: 30 days

Article 11.07 covers a felony judgment with any penalty but death, after final conviction. File the application with the clerk of the convicting court. The writ issues by operation of law, returnable to the Court of Criminal Appeals. The clerk sends a copy to the State, which must answer within 30 days after receiving it. Anything the State doesn't admit is deemed denied.

CCP art. 11.07 § 3(c)

Deadline: 20 days

Within 20 days after the State's answer time runs out, the convicting court decides whether there are controverted, previously unresolved facts material to the legality of confinement. "Confinement" includes any collateral consequence of the conviction. If the court does nothing in those 20 days, that counts as a finding that there are none, and the case goes up.

CCP art. 11.07 § 3(d)

If there are fact issues, the court enters an order designating them within the same 20 days. To resolve them, it may use affidavits, depositions, interrogatories, additional forensic testing, hearings, and its own recollection. It may appoint an attorney or a magistrate to hold a hearing and make findings.

CCP art. 11.07 § 6

Deadline: 7 days

Both sides get at least seven full days' notice before any hearing.

TRAP 73.5; 73.4(b)(5)

Deadline: 180 days

The convicting court must resolve designated issues within 180 days after the State received the application. On day 181, the district clerk forwards the record to the Court of Criminal Appeals unless that court granted an extension. Any extension motion must be filed in the CCA before the 180 days run.

TRAP 73.4(b)(2)

Deadline: 10 days

The clerk sends every filing and order to all parties. You have 10 days after receiving the trial court's findings of fact and conclusions of law to file objections, though the court may send the record up sooner.

TRAP 73.1

Use the CCA's prescribed form, and put every ground on it, with a summary of the supporting facts. Any ground not raised on the form won't be considered. Each ground gets the two pages the form provides. A separate memorandum may carry the law and argument, up to 15,000 words if computer-generated or 50 pages if not, with a word-count certificate. The application must be verified.

CCP art. 11.07 § 4

After an initial application is finally decided, a later one can't be considered on the merits unless it states specific facts showing one of two things. Either the factual or legal basis was unavailable when the earlier application was filed. Or, by a preponderance of the evidence, but for a federal constitutional violation, no rational juror could have found guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The statute defines "unavailable" for both legal and factual bases (§ 4(b)–(c)).

CCP art. 11.07 § 5; TRAP 73.6

The CCA may deny relief on the hearing judge's findings without docketing the case, docket and hear it, or deny relief on its own review of the application. After conviction, the 11.07 procedure is exclusive; any other proceeding to discharge the prisoner is void.

TRAP 79.2(d)

No motion for rehearing may be filed after the CCA denies relief or dismisses an 11.07 application. The Court may reconsider on its own initiative.

TRAP 73.7

Once the application reaches the CCA, new evidence is considered only by motion. You can ask the CCA to consider it directly, which it will grant only in truly exceptional circumstances. Or you can ask for leave to supplement the record in the trial court. If the CCA hasn't yet filed and set the case, move to stay while you file the evidence below.

CCP art. 11.072 §§ 2–3

For someone who is or was on community supervision, file in the court that imposed it. The application may challenge the conviction or order that imposed supervision, or its conditions. It isn't available if the relief could be had by appeal under art. 44.02 and TRAP 25.2. A challenge to a condition alone must be on constitutional grounds and must first go through a motion to amend the conditions.

CCP art. 11.072 §§ 5–8

Deadline: 30 + 60 days

Serve the State immediately. The State may answer within 30 days after service, plus one 30-day extension for good cause. Within 60 days after the answer, the trial court must enter a written order — either denying the application as frivolous or ruling with findings and conclusions. Either side may appeal under art. 44.02 or 44.01 and TRAP 31.

28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)(1)–(2)

Deadline: 1 year

The federal one-year clock runs from the latest of four dates — usually the day the state judgment becomes final. It stops only while a properly filed state post-conviction application is pending.

28 U.S.C. §§ 2254(a)–(b), 2244(b)(3)(A), 2253(c)

To get federal habeas, your client must be in custody and must have exhausted state remedies. A second or successive petition needs the court of appeals' permission first. And there's no appeal from a denial without a certificate of appealability.

Traps

  • Every ground goes on the form. A ground that appears only in the memorandum won't be considered (TRAP 73.1(c)).
  • Twenty days of silence from the trial court is a finding that there are no fact issues (CCP art. 11.07 § 3(c)).
  • No motion for rehearing after the CCA denies or dismisses an 11.07 (TRAP 79.2(d)). Get it right the first time.
  • An 11.072 denial goes to the court of appeals (CCP art. 11.072 § 8). An 11.07 goes to the CCA.
  • A subsequent 11.072 application has only the unavailability gateway. It has no innocence gateway like art. 11.07 § 4(a)(2) (CCP art. 11.072 § 9(a)).
  • A lost direct appeal gets restored by habeas in the Court of Criminal Appeals, not by the court of appeals.
  • Pin down the federal deadline first: the conviction date, the day direct review ended, and the filing and disposition dates of every state writ.
  • Headed to federal court? The federal track picks up here with § 2254: the one-year clock, exhaustion, and deference.

Downloads for this stage