Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Texas · At trial · Stage 3 of 10

Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof

Your evidence was objected to or kept out. Did you lay the foundation — and put it in the record?

Stage 3 of 10 · View all stages
  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

Now flip it around. Your client wanted the jury to hear something, and the judge said no. How can the court of appeals decide the judge was wrong about evidence it never saw? It can't — unless the record shows what the evidence was and why it was admissible. That's what an offer of proof does.

Do this

  1. Find the offer of proof, or confirm the evidence's substance was apparent from context (TRE 103(a)(2)).
  2. Check that the offer showed the foundation — the predicate — not just the evidence.
  3. If the evidence was admissible for only one purpose, check that the offer was limited to it (TRE 105(b)(2)).
  4. Nothing in the record? File a formal bill of exception within 60 days after sentencing, or 90 with a timely motion for new trial (TRAP 33.2(e)(2)).

See it

Decision treeThe court kept your evidence out. Now what?

Was its substance apparent from context?

  • Yes

    No offer of proof is needed.

    TRE 103(a)(2)

  • No

    Did you make an offer of proof — outside the jury, before the charge was read?

    • Yes

      Preserved. Make sure the offer shows the foundation too.

      TRE 103(a)(2), (c)

    • No

      Is it within 60 days after sentencing — or 90 with a timely motion for new trial?

      • Yes

        File a formal bill of exception.

        TRAP 33.2; 33.2(e)(2)

      • No

        The court of appeals may extend the deadline on a motion filed within 15 days after it.

        TRAP 33.2(e)(3)

Rules to know

TRE 104(a)–(b)

The judge decides preliminary questions — whether a witness is qualified, a privilege exists, or evidence is admissible — and isn't bound by the evidence rules except privilege. When relevance depends on a fact, you need proof sufficient to support a finding that the fact exists. The court may admit the evidence on the condition that you connect it up later.

TRE 901(a)–(b)

To authenticate an item, produce evidence sufficient to support a finding that it is what you say it is. The rule's examples include a witness with knowledge (b)(1); distinctive characteristics, taken with all the circumstances (b)(4); and evidence describing a process or system and showing that it produces an accurate result (b)(9).

TRE 803(6)

A business record comes in if it was made at or near the time, by or from someone with knowledge; kept in the course of a regularly conducted activity; and made as a regular practice of that activity. The custodian or another qualified witness proves those elements, or a Rule 902(10) affidavit does. The opponent can still keep it out by showing a lack of trustworthiness.

TRE 902(10)

Deadline: 14 days before trial

A business record with a compliant affidavit or unsworn declaration is self-authenticating if both were served on every party at least 14 days before trial. For good cause, the court may treat a record as presumptively authentic even without that service.

TRE 801(e)(2)

An opposing party's own statement isn't hearsay — when it's offered against that party. The rule covers statements the party made, adopted, or authorized; statements by the party's agent or employee within the scope of that relationship; and statements by a coconspirator during and in furtherance of the conspiracy.

TRE 105(b)(2)

If your evidence is admissible for one purpose but not another, you can complain about its exclusion only if you limited your offer to the purpose — or the party — for which it's admissible.

TRE 107

When the other side offers part of an act, declaration, conversation, writing, or recorded statement, you may bring in the rest on the same subject, plus anything needed to explain it or let the jury fully understand it.

TRE 613(a)

Before impeaching with a prior inconsistent statement, tell the witness its contents, and when, where, and to whom it was made. Give the witness a chance to explain or deny it. Extrinsic proof of the statement comes in only if the witness doesn't unequivocally admit making it.

TRE 103(a)(2), (c)

When the court keeps your evidence out, make an offer of proof showing its substance, unless context made it obvious. The court must let you make it as soon as practicable, outside the jury's presence, and before the charge is read. If you ask, the court must direct that it be made in question-and-answer form.

TRAP 33.2

If the complaint won't otherwise appear in the record, file a formal bill of exception. State the objection and the ruling specifically enough that the trial court knows the complaint. Present it to the judge first. If the parties agree, the judge signs it. If they don't, the judge must sign it, suggest corrections, or file the judge's own version. Then you may file yours with affidavits from at least three people who observed the matter (33.2(a), (c)).

TRAP 33.2(e)(2)–(3)

Deadline: 60 / 90 days

In a criminal case, file the formal bill no later than 60 days after sentence is pronounced or suspended in open court — or 90 days if a motion for new trial was timely filed. The appellate court may extend the time on a Rule 10.5(b) motion filed within 15 days after the deadline.

CCP art. 38.22 § 3(a)

Deadline: 20 days before

Know the other side's predicate, too. The State's recorded custodial statement is inadmissible unless it was electronically recorded; the warnings were given and waived on the recording; the device and operator were competent and the recording is accurate and unaltered; all voices are identified; and defense counsel got a true, complete copy at least 20 days before the proceeding. Name the missing element when you object.

Traps

  • Settled practice: an offer of proof should show both what the evidence was and the foundation that made it admissible, so the court of appeals can see the ruling was wrong.
  • "Improper predicate" alone isn't a specific objection. Say which element is missing (TRE 103(a)(1)(B)).
  • Your client's own out-of-court statement isn't an opposing party's statement when you offer it. That rule covers statements offered against the party who made them (TRE 801(e)(2)).
  • Admitted on condition and never connected up? Move to strike (TRE 104(b), 103(a)(1)(A)).
  • The bill of exception clock runs from sentencing, not from the notice of appeal: 60 days, or 90 with a timely motion for new trial (TRAP 33.2(e)(2)).