Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Federal · Starting the appeal · Stage 2 of 8

Post-trial motions and the notice of appeal

Which motions were filed, and when? That tells you whether the 14 days run from the judgment or from the last ruling.

Stage 2 of 8 · View all stages
  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Post-trial motions and the notice of appeal
  3. 3The record and the brief
  4. 4Harmless error and plain error
  5. 5After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari
  6. 6§ 2254: a state prisoner in federal court
  7. 7§ 2255: a federal prisoner's motion
  8. 8Appealing a habeas denial

Texas gives you 30 days to file a notice of appeal. How long does federal court give you? Fourteen. The notice goes to the district court, and only certain post-trial motions reset the clock.

Do this

  1. Count 14 days from the judgment's entry on the criminal docket (FRAP 4(b)(1)(A), (b)(6)).
  2. Determine whether a timely motion qualifies under FRAP 4(b)(3)(A). A Rule 33 motion based on newly discovered evidence affects the appeal deadline only if it was made within 14 days after entry of judgment.
  3. Don't rely on a Rule 35(a) motion to extend anything (FRAP 4(b)(5)).
  4. Missed it? Ask the district court to extend, for excusable neglect or good cause (FRAP 4(b)(4)).

See it

Decision treeWhen is the federal notice of appeal due?

Did your client timely file a post-trial motion?

  • No

    14 days after entry of the judgment (or the government's notice, if later).

    FRAP 4(b)(1)(A)

  • Yes — Rule 29 (acquittal), Rule 34 (arrest), or Rule 33 not based on newly discovered evidence

    14 days after the order resolving the last of them, or 14 days after judgment — whichever is later.

    FRAP 4(b)(3)(A)

  • Yes — Rule 33 based on newly discovered evidence

    Was it made within 14 days after entry of judgment?

    • Yes

      It postpones the deadline like the others: 14 days after the order resolving it.

      FRAP 4(b)(3)(A)(ii)

    • No

      It can be timely under Rule 33's three-year limit and still not postpone the notice. The notice is due 14 days after judgment.

      FRCrP 33(b)(1); FRAP 4(b)(3)(A)(ii)

  • Only a Rule 35(a) motion

    It doesn't postpone anything. The notice is due 14 days after judgment.

    FRAP 4(b)(5)

Missed it? For excusable neglect or good cause, the district court may extend the time by up to 30 days (FRAP 4(b)(4)).

Rules to know

FRAP 4(b)(1)(A)

Deadline: 14 days

Your client's notice of appeal is due in the district court 14 days after the later of two events: entry of the judgment or order, or the government's notice of appeal. The government gets 30 days (4(b)(1)(B)).

FRAP 4(b)(3)(A)

Certain timely motions reset the clock: judgment of acquittal (FRCrP 29), new trial (FRCrP 33 — a newly-discovered-evidence motion counts only if made within 14 days after judgment is entered), and arrest of judgment (FRCrP 34). The notice is then due 14 days after the order resolving the last of them, or 14 days after judgment, whichever is later.

FRCrP 29(c)(1), 33(b), 34(b)

Deadline: 14 days / 3 years

The motions have their own deadlines. Acquittal: 14 days after the guilty verdict or the jury's discharge, whichever is later. New trial on newly discovered evidence: 3 years after the verdict or finding of guilty. New trial on any other ground: 14 days. Arrest of judgment: 14 days after the court accepts the verdict, finding, or plea.

FRAP 4(b)(4)

Deadline: +30 days

For excusable neglect or good cause, the district court may extend the notice deadline — before or after it runs — by up to 30 days.

FRAP 4(b)(5)

Deadline: 14 days

A motion to correct clear sentencing error under FRCrP 35(a) — arithmetical, technical, or other clear error, within 14 days after sentencing — doesn't stop the appeal clock.

FRCrP 32(j)

After sentencing, the court must tell a client convicted after a not-guilty plea about the right to appeal the conviction. Whatever the plea, it must explain any right to appeal the sentence. If your client asks, the clerk must prepare and file the notice of appeal right away.

FRCrP 11(a)(2), 11(b)(1)(N)

With the court's and the government's consent, a conditional plea reserves, in writing, the right to appeal the denial of a specified pretrial motion. Before accepting any plea, the court must tell your client the terms of any plea-agreement waiver of the right to appeal or collaterally attack the sentence.

FRAP 4(c)(1)

A notice from a client in prison is timely if it goes into the institution's internal mail system by the last day, with a declaration or notarized statement giving the deposit date and saying postage is prepaid — or with evidence such as a postmark. If the institution has a legal-mail system, your client must use it.

FRAP 26(a)(1)

Counting days. Skip the day of the event that starts the clock, count every day after it, and include the last day. If the last day is a Saturday, Sunday, or legal holiday, the period runs to the end of the next day that isn't one.

Traps

  • A federal defendant has 14 days, not Texas's 30 (FRAP 4(b)(1)(A); compare TRAP 26.2(a)).
  • A Rule 35(a) motion doesn't stop the appeal clock (FRAP 4(b)(5)). Acquittal and arrest motions do, and so does a new-trial motion — but one based on newly discovered evidence counts only if made within 14 days after entry of judgment (4(b)(3)(A)).

Practice this stage

Try The Alvarado federal plea

More: Ybarra brief