Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Texas · Federal · Criminal appeals and habeas

Criminal appeals, rule by rule

An appeal begins where the trial ends: with the record. So this guide starts at trial and follows a criminal case, step by step, through the appeal and into habeas — in Texas courts and federal. Every card tells you what the rule says, and cites it.

How does your client's case move?

Choose the court system, then your client's situation. The steps appear below, in order, each linked to its lesson.

Already sentenced in Texas? Start here: Stage 4: Can your client appeal? · Stage 5: Motion for new trial · Stage 6: Notice of appeal and the record

Texas conviction: the appeal

  1. At trial

    Make the record

    Object, say why, and get a ruling. If the judge keeps your evidence out, make an offer of proof. The appeal can review only what's in this record.

    TRAP 33.1(a); TRE 103

    Texas stage 1: Preserve it at trial
  2. Sentencing day

    Check the right to appeal

    The judge certifies whether your client can appeal. Read the certification before you leave the courtroom.

    TRAP 25.2(a)(2), (d)

    Texas stage 4: Can you appeal?
  3. Within 30 days

    Motion for new trial, if you need new facts

    If a complaint depends on facts outside the record — often about trial counsel — file the motion now and present it within 10 days.

    TRAP 21.2, 21.4, 21.6

    Texas stage 5: Motion for new trial
  4. Within 30 days (90 with a motion for new trial)

    File the notice of appeal

    File it with the trial court clerk, not the court of appeals. Then request the reporter's record and arrange payment.

    TRAP 25.2(c); 26.2(a); 35.3(b)

    Texas stage 6: Notice of appeal and the record
  5. 30 days after the record is filed

    File your brief

    Follow TRAP 38.1's order, cite the record for every fact, and stay under 15,000 words.

    TRAP 38.1; 38.6(a); 9.4(i)

    Texas stage 7: Write the brief
  6. After the court rules

    Rehearing, then the PDR

    Rehearing is due in 15 days. A petition for discretionary review to the Court of Criminal Appeals is due in 30.

    TRAP 49.1; 68.2(a)

    Texas stage 9: After the opinion
  7. When review ends

    Postconviction review

    Identify the postconviction procedure that fits. Art. 11.07 covers final non-death felony convictions; supervision and misdemeanor cases have their own articles. Work out the federal limitations period alongside the state proceeding.

    CCP arts. 11.07, 11.072, 11.09(b); 28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)

    Texas stage 10: Beyond the appeal: habeas

Texas conviction: after the appeal

  1. First

    Pick the writ article

    Art. 11.07 for a final non-death felony conviction; 11.072 if your client is or was on community supervision; 11.071 for a death sentence.

    CCP arts. 11.07, 11.072, 11.071

    The following state-court steps describe Article 11.07. For community supervision, select the supervision route; for other writs, open the habeas stage.

    Texas stage 10: Beyond the appeal: habeas
  2. Filing

    Application with the convicting court's clerk

    Use the CCA's form and put every ground on it. The clerk sends it to the State.

    CCP art. 11.07 § 3(b); TRAP 73.1

    Texas stage 10: Beyond the appeal: habeas
  3. Within 30 days

    The State answers

    Anything the State doesn't admit is deemed denied.

    CCP art. 11.07 § 3(b)

    Texas stage 10: Beyond the appeal: habeas
  4. 20 days after that

    The judge decides whether facts are disputed

    If they are, the judge designates the issues and resolves them — by affidavits, hearings, or other means — within 180 days after the State received the application. Silence means no disputed facts.

    CCP art. 11.07 § 3(c)–(d); TRAP 73.5

    Texas stage 10: Beyond the appeal: habeas
  5. Then

    The Court of Criminal Appeals decides

    No motion for rehearing is allowed after a denial.

    CCP art. 11.07 § 5; TRAP 79.2(d)

    Texas stage 10: Beyond the appeal: habeas
  6. Within the federal year

    A § 2254 petition in federal court

    Time the state writ was pending doesn't count against the year. Plead every ground.

    28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)(2); § 2254 Rule 2(c)

    Federal stage 6: § 2254: a state prisoner in federal court
  7. If it's denied

    Certificate and notice

    You need a certificate of appealability and a notice of appeal within 30 days.

    28 U.S.C. § 2253(c); FRAP 4(a)(1)(A)

    Federal stage 8: Appealing a habeas denial

Texas: currently or previously on community supervision

  1. First

    Confirm art. 11.072 fits

    Your client must be, or have been, on community supervision, and the relief must not be available by appeal. If supervision was revoked and a sentence imposed, identify that judgment and whether direct review is available or pending.

    CCP art. 11.072 §§ 2–3

    Texas stage 10: Beyond the appeal: habeas
  2. Filing

    Application in the court that imposed supervision

    Serve the State right away. The State may answer within 30 days.

    CCP art. 11.072 § 5

    Texas stage 10: Beyond the appeal: habeas
  3. Within 60 days of the answer

    The judge rules in writing

    Either a denial as frivolous, or an order with findings of fact and conclusions of law.

    CCP art. 11.072 §§ 6–7

    Texas stage 10: Beyond the appeal: habeas
  4. If it's denied

    Appeal to the court of appeals

    The appeal runs under art. 44.02 and TRAP 31.

    CCP art. 11.072 § 8

    Texas stage 10: Beyond the appeal: habeas

Federal conviction: the appeal

  1. Before trial

    File pretrial motions on time

    Suppression, severance, discovery, and indictment defects usually must be raised before trial.

    FRCrP 12(b)(3)

    Federal stage 1: Preserve it at trial
  2. At trial

    Make the record

    Tell the judge what you want or what you object to, and why.

    FRCrP 51(b); FRE 103

    Federal stage 1: Preserve it at trial
  3. Within 14 days

    File the notice of appeal

    File it in the district court. Some post-trial motions reset the clock.

    FRAP 4(b)(1)(A), (b)(3)

    Federal stage 2: Post-trial motions and the notice of appeal
  4. Within 14 days of the notice

    Order the transcript

    In writing, with a copy to the district clerk.

    FRAP 10(b)(1)

    Federal stage 3: The record and the brief
  5. 40 days after the record is filed

    File your brief

    Follow FRAP 28(a)'s order and stay within 13,000 words.

    FRAP 31(a)(1); 32(a)(7)

    Federal stage 3: The record and the brief
  6. After the decision

    Rehearing, then cert

    Rehearing within 14 days; a cert petition within 90.

    FRAP 40(d)(1); Sup. Ct. R. 13.1

    Federal stage 5: After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari

Federal conviction: after the appeal

  1. Within a year of finality

    File a § 2255 motion

    In the court that sentenced your client, with every ground pleaded.

    28 U.S.C. § 2255(a), (f)

    Federal stage 7: § 2255: a federal prisoner's motion
  2. If it's denied

    Certificate and notice

    A notice of appeal within 60 days, and a certificate of appealability.

    FRAP 4(a)(1)(B); 28 U.S.C. § 2253(c)(1)(B)

    Federal stage 8: Appealing a habeas denial

Every stage, in order

Texas

State court: the TRAP, the Rules of Evidence, and the Code of Criminal Procedure.

  1. 1Preserve it at trialDid trial counsel object in time, say why, and get a ruling?
  2. 2Objections that trip people upThe objection was made. Was it the right one, at the right time, with the right follow-through?
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proofYour evidence was objected to or kept out. Did you lay the foundation — and put it in the record?
  4. 4Can you appeal?Sentencing is done. Does your client have a right to appeal — and did a plea bargain narrow it?
  5. 5Motion for new trialDoes the complaint need facts that aren't in the record yet?
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the recordIs the appeal perfected, and is the record on its way?
  7. 7Write the briefWhat goes in it, how long can it be, and when is it due?
  8. 8HarmEven if the court got it wrong, did it matter — and under which test?
  9. 9After the opinionYou lost in the court of appeals. What now, and how fast?
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeasThe appeal is over, or it was lost. How does a Texas writ actually move?

Federal

Federal court: direct appeals from federal convictions (stages 1–5), federal habeas for Texas prisoners under § 2254 (stage 6) and federal prisoners under § 2255 (stage 7), and appealing a habeas denial (stage 8).

  1. 1Preserve it at trialDid trial counsel tell the judge what was wrong, and why, when it mattered?
  2. 2Post-trial motions and the notice of appealWhich motions were filed, and when? That tells you whether the 14 days run from the judgment or from the last ruling.
  3. 3The record and the briefIs the transcript ordered? What goes in the brief, and how long can it run?
  4. 4Harmless error and plain errorPreserved or not, did the error affect substantial rights?
  5. 5After the opinion: rehearing and certiorariYou lost in the circuit. What now, and how fast?
  6. 6§ 2254: a state prisoner in federal courtState review is done. Does your client have a timely, exhausted federal claim?
  7. 7§ 2255: a federal prisoner's motionFederal conviction, direct appeal over. Is there a timely motion to vacate?
  8. 8Appealing a habeas denialThe district court denied relief. Is there a certificate, and is the notice on time?
Federal habeasWhere to fileThe four Texas districts and the Fifth Circuit: forms, local rules, and each court's own filing guidance. FoundationsElements, evidence, and burdensWhat must be proved, how much, and how the proof gets in — the questions under every stage. PracticeSample clients25 short fact patterns, Texas and federal. Spot the issue, then open the rules. ChecklistIssue spotterPreservation, standard of review, harm, and remedy for each complaint — Texas and federal side by side. DownloadFormsWorking forms that follow one DWI case from arrest to appeal — bond, discovery, suppression, new trial, notice. DownloadWorksheet and shell briefA short triage sheet, plus a Texas shell brief in TRAP 38.1 order. Download or print to complete.