Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Texas · Appellate review · Stage 7 of 10

Write the brief

What goes in it, how long can it be, and when is it due?

Stage 7 of 10 · View all stages
  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

Everything so far has been about building the record. The brief is where you use it. The rules fix its parts, their order, its length, and its due date; the rest is your argument. Start from the shell brief, fill in each part, and cite the record for every fact.

Do this

  1. Calendar the due date: 30 days after the later record is filed (TRAP 38.6(a)).
  2. Read the whole record, list every preserved issue, then lead with your strongest.
  3. Download the shell brief and follow TRAP 38.1's order.
  4. Stay under 15,000 words and add the word-count certificate (TRAP 9.4(i)(2)(B), (i)(3)).
  5. Want oral argument? Say so on the cover (TRAP 39.7).

See it

Step by stepThe briefing clock
  1. Start

    The later of the clerk's record or the reporter's record is filed.

  2. +30

    Your brief is due.

    TRAP 38.6(a)

  3. +30

    The State's brief is due, 30 days after yours is filed.

    TRAP 38.6(b)

  4. +20

    Your reply, if any, is due 20 days after the State's brief is filed.

    TRAP 38.6(c)

Anatomy of an appellate issue

An analytical map, not a formula. A record cite and a legal cite don't make an argument by themselves. The application connects them. Open each box.

The issue

One complaint about one ruling, stated so it covers every subsidiary question you'll argue.

TRAP 38.1(f)

Record

What happened below: the testimony, the objection, and the ruling, each with a record reference.

TRAP 38.1(g), (i)

Law

What should have happened: the rule, statute, or constitutional text that governs the ruling, cited.

TRAP 38.1(i)

Preservation

Can the court consider it at all? Find the timely, specific complaint and the ruling in the record.

TRAP 33.1(a) · Go to that stage

Standard of review

How the court examines the ruling. No Texas rule states it, so your brief supplies it. Federal briefs must state it for each issue.

FRAP 28(a)(8)(B)

Application

Why the ruling was wrong: the law applied to these record facts, under that standard. This is the argument itself.

TRAP 38.1(i)

Does the error warrant relief?

Error isn't yet relief. Pick the right harm test and argue it.

TRAP 44.2 · Go to that stage

What remedy follows?

What the court of appeals can do: affirm; modify and affirm; reverse and render; reverse and remand; vacate and dismiss; or dismiss the appeal. Ask for the one you need in the prayer.

TRAP 43.2; 38.1(j)

Rules to know

TRAP 38.1

In this order: (a) identity of parties and counsel; (b) table of contents; (c) index of authorities; (d) statement of the case — seldom more than half a page, and no facts; (e) a statement on oral argument, if you want one (one page at most; ask for argument on the cover, Rule 39.7); (f) issues presented; (g) statement of facts, with record references; (h) summary of the argument; (i) argument, citing authorities and the record; (j) prayer.

TRAP 9.4(i)(2)(B)–(C)

Word limits for computer-generated briefs: 15,000 words for a brief, 7,500 for a reply. A death-penalty direct-appeal brief gets 37,500 (9.4(i)(2)(A)).

TRAP 9.4(i)(1)

Every word counts — headings, footnotes, and quotations included. Leave out only the caption, identity of parties and counsel, statement regarding oral argument, table of contents, index of authorities, statement of the case, issues presented, statement of jurisdiction, statement of procedural history, signature, proof of service, certification, certificate of compliance, and appendix.

TRAP 9.4(i)(3)

Add a certificate stating the word count. You may rely on your software's count. Need more room? The court may allow a longer brief on motion (9.4(i)(4)).

TRAP 9.4(e)

Use a conventional typeface: at least 14-point in the text and 12-point in footnotes.

TRAP 38.6(a)–(b)

Deadline: 30 days

Your brief is due 30 days after the later of the clerk's record or the reporter's record is filed. The State's brief is due 30 days after yours is filed. Habeas and bail appeals follow Rule 31 instead.

TRAP 38.8(b)

A late brief in a criminal case doesn't get the appeal dismissed. If notice goes out and no satisfactory response comes within 10 days, the trial court must hold a hearing: Does the appellant still want to appeal? Is the appellant indigent? Has retained counsel abandoned the appeal?

Traps

  • Read TRAP 38.1(f) for what it gives you: a stated issue "will be treated as covering every subsidiary question that is fairly included." So the drafting task is not to list every sub-question — it is to state each issue concisely and broadly enough that the ones you plan to argue are fairly included in it.
  • Every fact needs a record cite (TRAP 38.1(g), (i)).

Practice this stage

Try The Mendoza brief