Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Texas · Appellate review · Stage 9 of 10

After the opinion

You lost in the court of appeals. What now, and how fast?

Stage 9 of 10 · View all stages
  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

The court of appeals ruled against your client. Now what? You can ask that court to take another look, and you can ask the Court of Criminal Appeals to take the case. But the CCA doesn't sit to correct every error; it takes cases for the reasons Rule 66.3 lists.

Do this

  1. Calendar rehearing (15 days) and the PDR (30 days) from the judgment (TRAP 49.1; 68.2(a)).
  2. Build the PDR around the court of appeals' decision and the Rule 66.3 reasons.
  3. Attach the opinion and stay within 4,500 words (TRAP 68.4; 9.4(i)(2)(E)).
  4. Write down the date the PDR is refused. It starts the cert clock and, later, the federal habeas year (Sup. Ct. R. 13.1).

See it

Step by stepAfter the court of appeals rules
  1. Day 0

    The court of appeals' judgment.

  2. +15

    Motion for rehearing due.

    TRAP 49.1

  3. +30

    PDR due, 30 days after the judgment or after the last timely rehearing motion is overruled.

    TRAP 68.2(a)

  4. +90

    If the CCA refuses the PDR: a cert petition is due 90 days after the refusal. If no PDR was sought, there is no cert window to add — direct review ended when the time for state review expired.

    Sup. Ct. R. 13.1

  5. Then

    When direct review is over — by that expiration, or by the Supreme Court's disposition — the federal habeas year ordinarily starts, unless a later start date applies.

    28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)(1)

Rules to know

TRAP 49.1

Deadline: 15 days

A motion for rehearing is due 15 days after the court of appeals' judgment. State clearly the issues you rely on.

TRAP 68.2

Deadline: 30 days

Your PDR is due 30 days after the court of appeals' judgment, or after it overrules the last timely motion for rehearing or en banc reconsideration. Another party then has 10 days after a timely petition to file its own. The Court of Criminal Appeals may extend the deadline on a Rule 10.5(b) motion filed within 15 days after it.

TRAP 66.2–66.3

Review is discretionary. The Court looks for a conflict among courts of appeals; an important question of state or federal law that should be settled; a conflict with the CCA or the U.S. Supreme Court; a statute held unconstitutional or misconstrued; justices who disagreed; and a departure from the usual course of proceedings.

TRAP 68.4; 9.4(i)(2)(E)

Keep the petition as short as you can. Address it to the Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas, state your grounds for review, and attach the court of appeals' opinion. The limit is 4,500 words — the same as a motion for rehearing.

TRAP 47.7(a)

An unpublished criminal opinion has no precedential value. You may still cite it, with the notation "(not designated for publication)."

CCP art. 44.29

If you win a new trial because of guilt-stage error, the case goes back as if the trial court had granted a new trial. If the error was only at punishment (in a non-capital case), the new trial starts at punishment, with guilt already found.

Traps

  • Build your PDR grounds around what the court of appeals decided and the reasons in Rule 66.3 — not around the trial court's error.

Practice this stage

Try The Delgado affirmance