Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Texas · Starting the appeal · Stage 5 of 10

Motion for new trial

Does the complaint need facts that aren't in the record yet?

Stage 5 of 10 · View all stages
  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

What if the problem isn't in the record at all — a witness trial counsel never called, a juror who talked about the case? The court of appeals can't consider facts it doesn't have. A motion for new trial is how you put them in, and a timely one also buys time for the notice of appeal.

Do this

  1. Decide soon after sentencing whether you need facts outside the record (TRAP 21.2).
  2. Gather affidavits now. The motion is due 30 days after sentencing (TRAP 21.4).
  3. Present it to the judge within 10 days after filing it (TRAP 21.6).
  4. Push for a hearing and a ruling within 75 days after sentencing (TRAP 21.8).
  5. A timely motion moves the notice deadline to 90 days (TRAP 26.2(a)(2)).

See it

Step by stepThe clock from sentencing
  1. Day 0

    Sentence imposed or suspended in open court.

  2. Day 30

    Motion for new trial due. If none is filed, the notice of appeal is due too.

    TRAP 21.4; 26.2(a)(1)

  3. +10

    Present the motion within 10 days after filing it.

    TRAP 21.6

  4. Day 60

    No motion filed: the record and any formal bill of exception are due.

    TRAP 35.2(a); 33.2(e)(2)(A)

  5. Day 75

    Last day for the court to rule by written order. A motion not timely ruled on is deemed denied when the 75 days expire (TRAP 21.8(c)).

    TRAP 21.8

  6. Day 90

    Timely motion filed: the notice of appeal and any formal bill are due.

    TRAP 26.2(a)(2); 33.2(e)(2)(B)

  7. +15

    Missed a notice deadline? File the notice and a Rule 10.5(b) motion within 15 days after it.

    TRAP 26.3

  8. Day 120

    Timely motion filed and denied: the record is due.

    TRAP 35.2(b)

Counted from the day sentence is imposed or suspended in open court. A last day on a weekend or legal holiday rolls forward (TRAP 4.1(a)).

Rules to know

TRAP 21.2

You need a motion for new trial to raise a point on appeal only when you have to bring in facts that aren't in the record.

TRAP 21.3

The court must grant a new trial when, among other grounds: your client was tried in absentia or denied counsel; the court misdirected the jury on the law or made another material error likely to hurt your client; the verdict was decided by lot; a juror was bribed or corrupt; force, threats, or fraud kept a defense witness away, or evidence of innocence was destroyed or withheld; or the jury misbehaved — for example, by taking in other evidence after it retired.

TRAP 21.4

Deadline: 30 days

File within 30 days after the court imposes or suspends sentence in open court. Within those 30 days you can amend without leave, as long as the court hasn't already overruled an earlier motion.

TRAP 21.6

Deadline: 10 days

Present the motion to the trial court within 10 days after filing it. The court may allow later presentment and a hearing, but no later than 75 days after sentencing.

TRAP 21.8

Deadline: 75 days

The court must rule within 75 days after sentencing. A grant takes a written order; a docket entry won't do. If the court doesn't rule in time, the motion is overruled by operation of law.

TRAP 26.2(a)(2)

Deadline: 90 days

A timely motion for new trial buys time: the notice of appeal is then due 90 days after sentencing.

Traps

  • Filing isn't presenting. Rules 21.4 and 21.6 run separate clocks.
  • Facts about ineffective assistance usually live outside the record. Build them in the motion for new trial (TRAP 21.2), or they wait for habeas.

Practice this stage

Try The Cantu lawyer