Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Texas · At trial · Stage 1 of 10

Preserve it at trial

Did trial counsel object in time, say why, and get a ruling?

Stage 1 of 10 · View all stages
  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

Can a court of appeals fix a mistake nobody pointed out at trial? Almost never. The record is the only thing that court gets to see. If the complaint isn't in it — made on time, with the reason stated, and ruled on — the court treats it as though it never happened, however good it is.

Do this

  1. For each possible issue, find the objection, motion, or request in the record.
  2. Check that it stated a specific ground, unless the ground was apparent from context (TRAP 33.1(a)(1)(A)).
  3. Find the ruling — or the refusal to rule and the objection to it (TRAP 33.1(a)(2)).
  4. Check whether a ruling at a hearing outside the jury made a repeat objection unnecessary (TRE 103(b)).
  5. Note anything that isn't in the record yet. It may need a motion for new trial or a bill of exception.

See it

Decision treeIs the complaint preserved?

Was there a timely request, objection, or motion?

  • No

    Not preserved. Look for fundamental error the court may notice anyway.

    TRAP 33.1(a)(1); TRE 103(e)

  • Yes

    Did it state the specific ground — or was the ground apparent from context?

    • No

      Not preserved.

      TRAP 33.1(a)(1)(A)

    • Yes

      Did the court rule?

      • Yes, expressly or implicitly

        Preserved.

        TRAP 33.1(a)(2)(A)

      • It refused to rule

        Did counsel object to the refusal?

Follow the objection

A short, made-up transcript from the Ortega trial. Open each line to see what it does for preservation. Then change one fact and watch the answer move.

ProsecutorDetective, what did the neighbor tell you when you got there?

This is what prompts the complaint: an out-of-court statement, offered through the detective.

DefenseObjection.

No ground stated. That preserves nothing unless the ground was apparent from context. TRE 103(a)(1)(B); TRAP 33.1(a)(1)(A)

CourtOverruled.

A ruling. The second requirement is met. TRAP 33.1(a)(2)(A)

WitnessShe said she saw him run out the back door.

The evidence is now in front of the jury.

On appealIssue one: the trial court erred by admitting hearsay.

The record shows no hearsay ground stated at trial. Unless context made it apparent, the complaint wasn't preserved. TRAP 33.1(a)(1)(A)

Change one fact

As it happened

Probably not preserved. Whether context made the hearsay ground apparent is the only argument left.

TRE 103(a)(1)(B); TRAP 33.1(a)(1)(A)

Counsel says "Objection, hearsay"

Preserved: a timely, specific objection and a ruling. The next question is harm.

TRE 103(a)(1); TRAP 33.1(a); 44.2(b)

The judge never rules, and counsel moves on

Not preserved unless the record shows an implicit ruling. A refusal to rule needs an objection to the refusal.

TRAP 33.1(a)(2)

Counsel objected at a hearing outside the jury, and the court ruled it admissible

Preserved. The objection doesn't have to be repeated in front of the jury.

TRE 103(b)

Flip it: the court kept out a defense witness, and counsel made an offer of proof

Preserved, if the offer showed the substance — outside the jury, before the charge was read.

TRE 103(a)(2), (c)

Rules to know

TRAP 33.1(a)

To raise a complaint on appeal, the record has to show three things. First, a timely request, objection, or motion. Second, the specific grounds, unless they were obvious from context. Third, a ruling — express or implied — or the judge's refusal to rule plus an objection to that refusal.

TRE 103(a)(1)

When evidence comes in, object or move to strike — on time and on the record — and state the specific ground, unless context made it obvious.

TRE 103(b)

If the court hears your objection outside the jury's presence and rules the evidence admissible, you don't have to object again.

TRE 103(e)

In a criminal case, the court may notice a fundamental error that affects a substantial right, even if nobody preserved it.

CCP art. 1.14(b)

Object to any defect in the indictment or information — form or substance — before trial on the merits begins. Wait, and the objection is gone for good: on appeal and in every postconviction proceeding.

CCP arts. 36.14, 36.15

Charge objections go in writing, before the charge is read to the jury, with each ground spelled out. They can reach errors in the charge and things it leaves out. A written requested instruction — or one dictated to the reporter — also preserves the error. No other exception is needed.

CCP art. 38.05

When ruling on admissibility, the judge may not comment on the weight of the evidence. And before the verdict, the judge may not say anything calculated to convey an opinion of the case.

Traps

  • "Objection" by itself preserves nothing unless the ground was obvious from context (TRE 103(a)(1)(B); TRAP 33.1(a)(1)(A)).
  • Make an offer of proof unless the excluded evidence's substance was apparent from context (TRE 103(a)(2)).
  • Your evidence got excluded? The next stage walks through predicates, offers of proof, and bills of exception.
  • Indictment defects die when trial starts (CCP art. 1.14(b)).
  • A sufficiency complaint needs no trial objection. The rules don't require any preservation step for it.