Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Federal · Collateral review · Stage 6 of 8

§ 2254: a state prisoner in federal court

State review is done. Does your client have a timely, exhausted federal claim?

Stage 6 of 8 · View all stages
  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Post-trial motions and the notice of appeal
  3. 3The record and the brief
  4. 4Harmless error and plain error
  5. 5After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari
  6. 6§ 2254: a state prisoner in federal court
  7. 7§ 2255: a federal prisoner's motion
  8. 8Appealing a habeas denial

Can a federal court undo a Texas conviction? Only for a violation of federal law, and only on federal terms. A § 2254 petition isn't a second appeal: the claims must be timely, they must have gone through the state courts first, and a state decision on the merits gets deference.

Do this

  1. Compute the one-year clock, leaving out the time a state writ was pending (28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)).
  2. For each claim, find where it was raised in state court (28 U.S.C. § 2254(b)).
  3. Plead every ground, signed under penalty of perjury (§ 2254 Rule 2(c)).
  4. Name the state officer who has custody as respondent (§ 2254 Rule 2(a)).

See it

Decision treeCan a § 2254 petition go forward?

Is your client in custody under a state-court judgment?

  • No

    Section 2254 reaches only people in custody under a state judgment.

    28 U.S.C. § 2254(a)

  • Yes

    Is the petition within one year — not counting time a properly filed state application was pending?

    • No

      Not necessarily barred. Check the statute's later start dates and state-application tolling. Beyond the text, settled practice recognizes equitable tolling and an actual-innocence gateway in narrow cases. Research both before concluding the petition is late.

      28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)(1)(B)–(D), (d)(2)

    • Yes

      Has each claim been exhausted in state court?

      • No

        Can't be granted unless state process is absent or ineffective. The court may still deny it on the merits.

        28 U.S.C. § 2254(b)

      • Yes

        Did the state court decide the claim on the merits?

        • Yes

          Relief only through § 2254(d): a decision contrary to, or an unreasonable application of, Supreme Court law, or an unreasonable fact determination.

          28 U.S.C. § 2254(d)

        • No

          Section 2254(d)'s limit applies by its terms only to merits decisions. State fact findings are still presumed correct.

          28 U.S.C. § 2254(e)(1)

A second or successive petition needs the court of appeals' authorization first (28 U.S.C. § 2244(b)(3)(A)).

The clock, interval by intervalThe federal year, with a state writ in the middle

Luna's dates: the CCA refused the PDR Mar. 4, 2025; no cert petition; art. 11.07 filed Jan. 10, 2026 and denied Aug. 12, 2026. Counting convention for this example: Civil Rule 6(a) (exclude the trigger day, count every day, roll a weekend last day), with the state application treated as pending from its filing day through its disposition day. This worked example uses the stated dates and counting assumptions. Recalculate using the dates in your case.

  1. Clock running · 221 days June 3, 2025 → Jan. 9, 2026

    The time to seek cert ran out June 2, 2025 — 90 days after the PDR refusal. The year starts counting the next day.

    Sup. Ct. R. 13.1; 28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)(1)(A)

  2. Clock stopped · 215 days Jan. 10 → Aug. 12, 2026

    A properly filed state application is pending. This time doesn't count.

    28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)(2)

  3. Clock running again · 144 days Aug. 13, 2026 → Jan. 3, 2027

    144 days remain. The last day, Sunday, Jan. 3, 2027, rolls to Monday, Jan. 4, 2027.

    28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)(1); FRCP 6(a)(1)(C)

Rules to know

28 U.S.C. § 2254(a)

A federal court hears the petition only on the ground that your client is in custody in violation of the Constitution, laws, or treaties of the United States.

28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)(1)

Deadline: 1 year

One year, running from the latest of: (A) the day the judgment became final, when direct review ended or the time to seek it ran out; (B) the day an unconstitutional state-created impediment to filing was removed; (C) the day the Supreme Court newly recognized the right, if it's retroactive on collateral review; or (D) the day the facts could have been discovered with due diligence.

28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)(2)

The time a properly filed state post-conviction application is pending doesn't count.

28 U.S.C. § 2254(b)(1), (c)

Relief requires exhausting available state remedies, unless state process is absent or ineffective. A claim isn't exhausted while any available state procedure could still raise it. The State waives exhaustion only expressly, through counsel ((b)(3)). The court may deny a petition on the merits even if a claim isn't exhausted ((b)(2)).

28 U.S.C. § 2254(d)

If the state court decided the claim on the merits, relief takes one of two showings. Either the decision was contrary to, or an unreasonable application of, clearly established federal law as determined by the Supreme Court (d)(1). Or it rested on an unreasonable determination of the facts in light of the state-court evidence (d)(2).

28 U.S.C. § 2254(e)

State-court findings of fact are presumed correct, and your client must rebut them by clear and convincing evidence. If your client didn't develop the facts in state court, there's no evidentiary hearing unless two things are true. The claim must rest on a new retroactive rule or on facts that couldn't have been discovered. And those facts must show, by clear and convincing evidence, that no reasonable factfinder would have convicted.

§ 2254 Rule 2(c), 2(a)

The petition must list every available ground, the facts supporting each, and the relief requested, signed under penalty of perjury. Name as respondent the state officer who has custody.

§ 2254 Rules 4, 5(b)

The judge must dismiss if it plainly appears your client isn't entitled to relief. If the petition survives, the State's answer must say whether any claim is barred by failure to exhaust, a procedural bar, non-retroactivity, or the statute of limitations.

28 U.S.C. § 2244(b)

A claim raised in an earlier petition gets dismissed. A new claim in a second or successive petition gets dismissed too, unless it rests on a new retroactive rule of constitutional law, or on facts that couldn't have been discovered earlier plus clear and convincing evidence of innocence. The court of appeals must authorize the filing first ((b)(3)(A)).

28 U.S.C. § 2254(i)

Ineffective counsel in federal or state collateral proceedings is not, by itself, a ground for relief.

28 U.S.C. § 2242

The application must be in writing, signed and verified by the person it's for or by someone acting on their behalf. It must allege the facts of the detention, who has custody, and by what authority, if known. It may be amended or supplemented as the civil rules allow.

§ 2254 Rules 4, 5(a)

Deadline: set by court order

Response deadline: set by court order. The judge screens the petition and must dismiss it if it plainly shows no entitlement to relief. If it isn't dismissed, the judge orders the respondent to answer or take other action within a fixed time. The respondent doesn't have to answer until ordered. Check the docket and the order itself — don't calendar a response date from the statute.

28 U.S.C. § 2243

Background, and not the petition-response schedule. The general habeas statute speaks of awarding the writ or ordering the respondent to show cause, a return within three days (extendable to twenty for good cause), and a hearing day set after the return. In a § 2254 case the governing rules supply the procedure instead: screening under Rule 4, and a response only when and as the judge orders.

28 U.S.C. §§ 2261(a)–(b), 2265

Capital cases have a separate chapter with faster deadlines — but only if it applies. It reaches § 2254 cases brought by state prisoners under a capital sentence, and only if the U.S. Attorney General certifies that the state has a qualifying mechanism for appointing postconviction counsel, and counsel was appointed, validly waived, retained, or the prisoner was found not indigent. Whether a state qualifies at any given time is a fact to check, not an assumption.

28 U.S.C. §§ 2263, 2266

Deadline: 180 days

If that chapter applies, the petition is due 180 days after the state court's final affirmance on direct review, or when the time for seeking review expires. The clock is tolled while a cert petition is pending and while the first state post-conviction application is pending, and the district court may allow up to 30 more days for good cause. The district court must then decide within 450 days after filing, or 60 days after submission, whichever is earlier, and the court of appeals within 120 days after the reply brief.

From Law Nerd's federal-habeas framework

Federal habeas is a challenge in federal court to a state conviction or sentence obtained in violation of federal law. It is not a retrial or a second appeal. It follows available Texas review; it does not replace it. Two gates end most late-stage cases before a judge reaches the merits: the one-year deadline and procedural default. A valid guilty plea waives most pre-plea defects. In a plea case the federal theories that commonly survive include an unknowing or involuntary plea, an invalid waiver of counsel, counsel's deficient advice that caused the plea, and innocence as a gateway — and a plea does not foreclose everything: claims going to the government's power to bring the case at all, events after the plea, an unlawful sentence, a broken plea agreement, and anything outside the scope of an express collateral-review waiver can still be raised. Develop the record in state court. It is usually the only record you will get.

Traps

  • A pending federal petition doesn't stop the one-year clock. Only a properly filed state application does (28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)(2)).
  • Plead every ground now. Rule 2(c)(1) requires all available grounds, and § 2244(b) sharply limits a second petition.
  • You won't find procedural default in § 2254's text. Rule 5(b) mentions "a procedural bar" only as something the State's answer must address. Settled practice treats a claim the state court rejected on an adequate state procedural ground as defaulted.
  • Chapter 154's capital deadlines are short, and they apply only on the Attorney General's certification (28 U.S.C. § 2261(b)). Check the state's current status before you rely on either timetable.

Practice this stage

Try The Luna federal petition

Next in this procedure

Appealing a § 2254 decision: certificate and notice

§ 2254 is for a state judgment. A federal judgment goes to § 2255 — a different procedure, not the next step after a § 2254 denial.

Curriculum order: Stage 7: § 2255: a federal prisoner's motion

← Back to Stage 5: After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari