Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Texas · Appellate review · Stage 8 of 10

Harm

Even if the court got it wrong, did it matter — and under which test?

Stage 8 of 10 · View all stages
  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Objections that trip people up
  3. 3Getting it in: predicates and offers of proof
  4. 4Can you appeal?
  5. 5Motion for new trial
  6. 6Notice of appeal and the record
  7. 7Write the brief
  8. 8Harm
  9. 9After the opinion
  10. 10Beyond the appeal: habeas

Say you convince the court the trial judge got it wrong. Do you win? Not yet. The court then asks whether the mistake mattered — and how it asks depends on the kind of mistake. Name the right test and argue it.

Do this

  1. For each issue, decide whether it's charge error, constitutional error, or other error.
  2. Apply the matching test: CCP art. 36.19, TRAP 44.2(a), or TRAP 44.2(b).
  3. Point to what in the record shows the error mattered.
  4. Ask for the specific remedy in your prayer (TRAP 38.1(j); 43.2).

See it

Decision treeWhich harm test?

First: was the jury charge actually wrong?

  • No error in the charge

    No charge-error harm analysis. Check the other issues.

  • Yes, the charge was wrong

    Did counsel object at trial?

    • Yes

      Reverse if the error was calculated to injure your client's rights. Settled practice calls this "some harm."

      CCP art. 36.19

    • No

      Reverse only if the record shows your client did not have a fair and impartial trial. Settled practice calls this "egregious harm."

      CCP art. 36.19

  • Not a charge issue

    Is the error constitutional?

    • Yes

      Reverse unless the court finds, beyond a reasonable doubt, that it didn't contribute to the conviction or punishment.

      TRAP 44.2(a)

    • No

      Disregard it unless it affects substantial rights.

      TRAP 44.2(b)

Rules to know

TRAP 44.2(a)

Constitutional error that's subject to harmless-error review requires reversal unless the court decides, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the error didn't contribute to the conviction or punishment.

TRAP 44.2(b)

Any other error, defect, irregularity, or variance gets disregarded unless it affects substantial rights.

CCP art. 36.19

Charge error doesn't require reversal unless it was calculated to injure your client's rights, or the record shows your client didn't get a fair and impartial trial. Settled practice applies the first clause when counsel objected ("some harm") and the second when no one did ("egregious harm").

TRE 103(a)

An evidence ruling is reversible only if it affects a substantial right.

Traps

  • Name the harm standard in your brief — constitutional (44.2(a)) or not (44.2(b)) — and argue it.
  • The rules don't state standards of review. Your brief has to supply them.