Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Federal · In the district court · Stage 1 of 8

Preserve it at trial

Did trial counsel tell the judge what was wrong, and why, when it mattered?

Stage 1 of 8 · View all stages
  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Post-trial motions and the notice of appeal
  3. 3The record and the brief
  4. 4Harmless error and plain error
  5. 5After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari
  6. 6§ 2254: a state prisoner in federal court
  7. 7§ 2255: a federal prisoner's motion
  8. 8Appealing a habeas denial

Is federal court different? Less than you might think: tell the judge what's wrong and why, when the ruling happens. The difference is timing. Suppression, indictment defects, and a few other claims usually must be raised before trial, or they're late.

Do this

  1. For each issue, find the objection or request and the ground stated (FRCrP 51(b)).
  2. For suppression, severance, discovery, and indictment defects, check the pretrial motion deadline (FRCrP 12(b)(3), (c)).
  3. For instructions, find the objection made before the jury retired (FRCrP 30(d)).
  4. Anything unpreserved gets plain-error review only (FRCrP 52(b)).

See it

Decision treeIs the federal claim preserved?

Is it a claim Rule 12(b)(3) says must be raised before trial — and was its basis reasonably available then?

  • Yes

    Was it raised by pretrial motion by the deadline?

    • Yes

      Timely. Get a ruling.

      FRCrP 12(b)(3), (c)(1)

    • No

      Untimely. The court may still consider it for good cause.

      FRCrP 12(c)(3)

  • No — an ordinary trial ruling

    When the ruling was made or sought, did you tell the court what you wanted, or object and give grounds?

    • Yes

      Preserved. Harm is tested under Rule 52(a).

      FRCrP 51(b)

    • No

      Plain-error review only.

      FRCrP 52(b)

    • There was no chance to object

      The missing objection doesn't prejudice you.

      FRCrP 51(b)

Rules to know

FRCrP 51(b)

To preserve an error, tell the judge — when the ruling is made or sought — what you want the court to do, or what you object to and why. You don't need to take an exception (51(a)). And if you had no chance to object, the missing objection won't hurt you later.

FRE 103(a)

When evidence comes in, object or move to strike on time and on the record, and state the specific ground unless context made it obvious. When evidence is kept out, make an offer of proof unless its substance was obvious from context.

FRE 103(b)

Once the court rules definitively on the record — before or at trial — you don't need to renew the objection or offer of proof.

FRCrP 12(b)(3), (c)(3)

Some claims must be raised by pretrial motion if the basis is reasonably available then: defects in starting the prosecution, defects in the indictment, suppression, severance, and Rule 16 discovery. Miss the deadline and the motion is untimely, though the court may still consider it for good cause. If the court sets no deadline, it's the start of trial (12(c)(1)).

FRCrP 30(d)

To object to an instruction, or to the refusal of one you asked for, state the specific objection and grounds before the jury retires. Skip that, and appellate review is limited to Rule 52(b).

FRCrP 29(a), (c)(3)

On a motion for judgment of acquittal, the court must acquit on any offense the evidence can't support. And your client can move after the jury is discharged without having moved before the case went to the jury.

Traps

  • Suppression is a pretrial motion, not a trial objection. If the basis was reasonably available, raising it for the first time at trial is too late unless there's good cause (FRCrP 12(c)(3)).
  • State the ground. An objection without one preserves nothing unless context made it obvious (FRE 103(a)(1)(B)).
  • Preserving is one question; the standard that follows is another. For preserved error, identify whether it is constitutional, nonconstitutional, or structural before you argue harm — the three take different treatment, and only the first two are weighed for harm at all.