Law Nerd LLCThe Appellate Arc

Federal · Collateral review · Stage 8 of 8

Appealing a habeas denial

The district court denied relief. Is there a certificate, and is the notice on time?

Stage 8 of 8 · View all stages
  1. 1Preserve it at trial
  2. 2Post-trial motions and the notice of appeal
  3. 3The record and the brief
  4. 4Harmless error and plain error
  5. 5After the opinion: rehearing and certiorari
  6. 6§ 2254: a state prisoner in federal court
  7. 7§ 2255: a federal prisoner's motion
  8. 8Appealing a habeas denial

The district court denied relief. Can your client appeal? Only with a certificate of appealability — and even with one, you still must file a timely notice of appeal.

Do this

  1. File the notice of appeal within 30 days, or 60 in a § 2255 case (FRAP 4(a)(1)).
  2. If the district court denied a certificate, ask a circuit judge (FRAP 22(b)(1)).
  3. Name the issues that make a substantial showing that a constitutional right was denied (28 U.S.C. § 2253(c)(2)–(3)).
  4. A motion to reconsider the denial of a certificate of appealability doesn't extend the appeal deadline (§ 2254 Rule 11(a)). Separately check whether a postjudgment motion qualifies under FRAP 4(a)(4).

See it

Decision treeAppealing a habeas denial

Did the district court grant a certificate of appealability?

  • Yes

    File a notice of appeal anyway — within 30 days, or 60 in a § 2255 case.

    § 2254 Rule 11(b); FRAP 4(a)(1)

  • No

    File the notice on time and ask a circuit judge for a certificate. With no express request, the notice counts as one.

    FRAP 22(b)(1)–(2)

A motion to reconsider the certificate denial doesn't extend the time to appeal (§ 2254 Rule 11(a)).

Rules to know

28 U.S.C. § 2253(c)(1)–(3)

Without a certificate of appealability, there's no appeal from the final order in a § 2254 case arising from state process, or in a § 2255 case. A certificate issues only on a substantial showing that a constitutional right was denied, and it must name the specific issues that meet that showing.

§ 2254 Rule 11(a); § 2255 Rule 11(a)

When the district court enters a final order against your client, it must grant or deny a certificate. You can't appeal a denial, but you can ask the court of appeals for a certificate under FRAP 22. A motion to reconsider the denial doesn't extend the time to appeal.

FRAP 4(a)(1)

Deadline: 30 / 60 days

The notice is due 30 days after the judgment or order is entered — or 60 days if a party is the United States, a U.S. agency, or a U.S. officer or employee as the rule describes.

FRAP 22(b)

If the district judge denied a certificate, ask a circuit judge. If you file no express request, the notice of appeal counts as one. The State and the United States don't need a certificate to appeal.

Traps

  • The notice of appeal is due even when the court grants a certificate (Rule 11(b)). They're two separate things.
  • A habeas appeal runs on the civil clock — 30 days, or 60 in a § 2255 case, where the United States is a party. The 14-day criminal clock doesn't apply (FRAP 4(a)(1); compare 4(b)(1)(A)).
  • Count the days under FRAP 26(a)(1), set out in Stage 2. A last day on a weekend or legal holiday moves to the next day that isn't one.

Practice this stage

Try The Peña § 2255

More: Quintero COA